Published the 1st and 15th of each month.
The egoist
AN INDIVIDUALIST REVIEW.
Formerly the NEW FREEWOMAN.
No. 19.— Vol. I.
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 1st, 1914.
Sixpence.
Editor: HARRIET SHAW WEAVER.
Amttant Editor: RICHARD ALDINGTON.
CONTENTS.
Contributing Editor:
DORA MARSDEN, B.A.
Page.
I'AGE.
Women's '• Rights." By Dora
Marsden
Views and Comments
Fighting Paris. By Madame
Ciolkowskn...
Tub Sonos of Mai.oorok. (lllu.s-
301 t rated). By the Comte de
Lautreamo&t 370
;i "* | Some Italian Sonnets. Translated
by John Felton 37+
3fifi The Prose op Frederic Manning.
By Richard Aldington 374
Art and Drama. By Him My Carter
The Secret op Disillusionment.
By Charles J. Whitby
contrasts. By M. 0.
Correspondence
Page.
376
378
379
379
WOMEN'S "RIGHTS."
By Dora Marsden.
THE War— .still the War— has brought the
wordy contest about Women's Rights to an
abrupt finish, and only a few sympathetic
words remain to be spoken over the feminist corpse.
Two parties were quarrelling about the validity of
the one party's claims to " rights," and without
any warning preliminaries both parties, with the
rest of the world, stand spectators a( a demonstration
in the natural history of "rights." To "rights"
in their maturity we have all been accustomed. Men
as well as women had become so implicated in their
matured existence that all were inclined to forget
that " rights " had an era of birth and consolidation,
as well as a period of maturity. The *' Women's
Rights " agitation was working industriously on the
assumption that rights were conferred by ordination,
and could be allowed bv goodwill and favour, when
the War arrived to shatter it. Incidentally it clears
up a confusion between " absolute rights " and
"courtesy rights": a confusion which has already
addled not only the " Women's Rights " agitation,
but also the proletarian agitation, and was within
measuring distance of placing the German Emperor
in the position of schoolmaster, authorised by divine
right to enlighten the world as to the difference. The
confusion has arisen out of an assumption that
ultimate authority lies in words; that every differ-
ence can be settled amicably if only it is argued
earnestly enough ; that courts of arbitration are
final ; that the legislature is the fount of power. The
Legislature, as merely the channel of power, has
seemed a contradictory, illogical, perversely in-
clined institution to the vast body of opinion which
starts out on its reasonings from the base that " Iu
the beginning was the Word." Accordingly the
" rights-claiming " women were only one band of a
company of humanitarian, pacifist, proletarian,
Christian believers, to whom the regarding of words
as secondary phenomena, addenda attaching to
forces with function merely to describe, assist, dis-
guise and defend such, as circumstances might
require, was simple blasphemy. As they mow stand
spectator to the birth-throes of a revised order of
rights, horror at the blasphemy is the substance of
their mutterings against the forces which have
compelled the revision. Their curses do not spare
their eves the spectacle all the same; the forces take
their course, leaving the verbalists to put what
interpretation they please on them, since interpreta-
tions are as little germane to the forces as straws are
to the force of a torrent which sweeps them along.
What would be germane to the forces would be an
exercise of force like their own ; short of such
exercise, words have the value — and no more — of the
detonation of the combatants' guns: they have
effects which impress the timid and the simple.
* * * *
At present, in the greater part of four continents,
all " rights " are suspended, and if, owing to favour-
able situation of locality, and the force of long
habit, the effect of possessing rights still continues,
it can be regarded only as an accidental escape. In
the countries at war the inhabitants are entitled to
the rights of the inhabitants of Louvain, or to those
of two aviators fighting in the air — i.e., to what they
can get. Civil rights, as well as courtesy rights,
circumstances have called iu, pending a settlement
of fundamental rights, the rights which tally with
the arbitrament of might when exhaustion compels
one body of combatants to ask for terms. Tbose
terms will he the "absolute right " at the moment
of settlement, and will he the foundation and the
ultimate authorisation of all subsequent civil or per-
mitted courtesy rights, both of which species of right
those who control the armed forces of a community
cau abrogate whenever they see fit. The granting
ol civil rights, in ihe main, follows a tendency
dictated by the nature of settlement with absolute
lights: those in control granting rights to those who
appeal capable of making serious trouble if they are
362
THE EGOIST
October 1, H»L*
not granted. Might even in these deluding times still
forms nine parts of most laws; the tenth part is the
''scrap of paper" to correspond: the ocular evidence
of might constituting a " right." Should the nine parts
vary the tenth will rapidly vary to correspond, the flux
of rights being only the outer evidence of the inner
spiritual flux of might. Might is spirit : there is no
doubt of that. All great military commanders, and the
commonest observations of ordinary men, agree in that.
.Spirit translates itself as might— physical superiority- 1 -*
simple phenomenon of the spirit which verbalists seek
to cover by labelling — in a hybrid lingo— spirit as morale
The great charters embodying new rights have all been
given in response lo actual or threatened insurrections
in might- ('.'•., in spirit — of those who desired them, and
as such they fall into harmony with the spirit of the
absolute rights actually established at the sword's point.
Between such rights and the courtesy rights which men
have conferred on women there is a swing almost to an
opposite ; a sweep of difference, bridged to a certain
degree by what may be called "bluffed rights "—rights
conferred by astute politicians with an eye to popular
favour in response to agitations too utterly feeble ever
to put their issue to the test of any tribunal other than
that of words and intrigue. It is a highly pernicious
process, because it misleads and subdues spirit, and it
is to this increasing vogue of ultra-modern political
institutions that the "Woman's Rights" agitation is
largely due. Such a vogue existing, women, naturally,
who have to obtain most of their material requirements
by "courtesy" means — by request and persuasion —
could not be expected to believe that there existed any-
thing obtainable on terms of talk which men might
obtain but which women might not. Hence a " move-
ment " founded in confusion: a confusion which women
may truly say they became immersed in only when men
themselves had become lost in it, and out of which,
intellectually speaking, it has been left to the women
themselves to make clear a way.
Women's ready acquiescence in the humanitarian
belief that, back of all things, stands the "Word"
(translated into practice that means that all powers
flow from laws), led them to make the request —
acidulated later into a demand— that they should be
allowed to participate in the making of the laws. The
request's refusal led to the reviewing of woman's status
in the community, and it was the evidence brought to
light in the reviewing which became in its turn account-
able for an increasing acridity in the "request." For
the first time women became aware in a general way of
their secondary position — a realisation which, un-
accountably as it may seem ;o men, came as a genuine
shock to their pride, the reason for the surprise being
that women, since men became articulate, have been the
plcasedly persuaded victims of men's flattery. Women's
actions, of course, flattered men; they were not
sufficiently articulate to flatter thpni in words. Men,
on the other hand, flattered mainly by words and
women, believed in the superiority which men ascribed
to them. The women who have an unshaken faith in
the actuality of the lofty status ascribed to " woman "
by the penny novellette far exceed in numbers those
who have, at any time, followed the banner of the
"Rebel Women." Hence the uupalatableness of the
" facts,'' and the determination to alter their character
at the. first opportunity: hence the determination of
" advanced " women to ladle out to themselves " rights "
from their primary source — as they imagine, the
legislature. Hence the "Votes for Women" agitation.
A slightly increased power of observation in women
made them aware that, while they were competent to
secure for themselves every kind of material advantage,
there existed a species of initiatory power, over and
above all material wealth -and in fact the source of it—
into touch with which their existent competence seemed
powerless to bring them. Tiny had the power to drasv
to themselves the results of the initiatory power where
they found themselves belonging to men whose initiatory
activity was satisfactory: they had no difficulty in
securing their bwn aggrandising with every form of
wealth and comfort. They were the passive recipients
on whom men — the active members— heaped their spoils.
Physically weak, their men protected them as valuable
property J mentally slow and unimaginative, men could
win them by the evidence and results of their own
mental alertness and imaginativeness, as they could
keep them pleased and content with the flattering
interpretation they placed upon the relationship. Men
called them their "property" only when annoyed—
their "own " was the more passionate and poetic — tin \
were the masculine complement, and the better half at
that ; the stable passive element which was always
reliable— and always there like the house and the farm-
stock. In short, women found that the only thing which
put men out was, not extravagance or graspingness, but
a desire for activity beyond a circumscribed limit.
Women's extravagance and irresponsibility has been
regarded, in fact, always with indulgent eye as a very
venal foible: but any enlarging ot the sphere of activity
was frowned down as " dewomanising," shewing a
brcak-dowu in fundamental womanly instinct. The
whole weight of man's imagination, his " idealism," his
pictured desire as to what women could mean for him
was, is, set directly against it. Women imagined that
" an appeal to reason " would win them their point
(such as they vaguely conceived it). Off-hand they
soothed themselves that their powers had failed in the
particular direction for lack of insistence: lack of laying
claim to it. Later, they found that by claiming il thpy
had put themselves further off from its attainment than
they would have been by quiet requesting and patient
waiting for its conferment. The more they sought to
strengthen their claims with reasons, the easier it
became to frame opposition against it. They failed to
appreciate that the appeal was silenced in advance by
the counter-assault on vanity and pride; and where
women are concerned vanity is m;.n's main feature. It
is the pride of possession which has made it a com-
paratively easy task for women to turn men into
toiling, hard-pressed] monotonous money-grubbers; and
it is a most delicately ironical fate that confused
observation should have led women into an attempt to
carry the assault against men's vanity, when at the same
time they proposed increasing the pressure on men's
responsibility.
Confused observation is the only explanation of the
trend which has been set to the "Woman's Movement "
during the century and more which constitute its first
stage, and to which the war has now affixed the term.
For instance, only confusion could account for women's
umbrage at being "properly," while at the same time
they insist on retaining and augmenting those protective
advantages they are possessed of, just because they are
property. Property is that which, being a non-initiatory
body, can offer no self-defence, and becomes, automati-
cally, the possession of those who can best defend it.
This does not mean to say it has no value:— its value
increases with the power of its owner; one may not cast
a glance awry at the smallest possession of* the very
powerful, but its value is to its possessor, not
to itself. " Property rights" is a misnomer: accurately
they are " property o-rmr'* rights," just as it is
"property-oirii.v'.'c responsibility." The property itself
can have neither rights nor responsibilities. The rights
of the owners work out at an agreed claim to accord and
receive neighbourly assistance in the work of protecting
the hold over one's property, and are based on reciprocal
claims that earh owner shall prevent his property from
becoming a nuisance, either from allowing it to " run
wild" or fall into such decay as to affect the well-being
of his neighbours. Thus women, being property, have
no rights beyond "courtesy" permitted ones: but their
owners have responsibilities towards them., which at
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
363
their minimum they must fulfil because of the demands
of their fellow-owners, and at their maximum in order
to gratify vanity in the pride of possession, and to
increase that attraction between women and their
owners, which is at the root-cause of men's assumption
of responsibility.
* « * *
The stronger, therefore, the call for protection, the
stronger is the implication that the responsible one is
the owner and the protected one the property; and as
it is the " advanced women" who have pushed the
claims of masculine responsibility to hitherto un-
dreamed of lengths, the fact that it is they also who
make the outcry against women being "property"
invests the movement with the element of uproarious
farce: the more so because they themselves remain
sublimely unconscious of any element of humour. This
explains why, by comparison with the " advanced
women," the "womanly" women look the more intelli-
gent. Actually there is, at present, no difference
between the main objectives of either: they both seek to
augment their status through the obliging acquiescence
of their mankind, but they differ as to the means. Both
want advantage in material affairs by civil means: that
is, by avoidance of an appeal to physical force to which
a male subject class would have to resort if it wished
to carry an insurrectionary point, but the "womanly"
women have the sense to see that such a procedure can
only be put through by "courtesy" means. The desire
for heightened status which is embodied in the
"advanced" women's (Irmmuls to share in initiatory
power, of course puts the "courtesy " attitude for them
out of the question: they feel they must needs demand
because power is their right. A vague instinct that
power must be self-bestowed is perhaps behind their
"fight" for parliamentary enfranchisement. They
imagine when they have laid hands on voting-power they
will be at the source of initiatory power: that they will
then be "free" (i.e., powerful) to help themselves.
While this struggle for voting power has been proceed-
ing, there has been too much heat engendered for the
women to become aware that the reviewing of their
position, which has revealed so much to them, has like-
wise been bringing into full consciousness in men's mind
a realisation of women's position which was only sub-
consciously realised before. It is ceasing to be regarded
as an unquestionable, divinely-ordained law of the
universe that men should be " responsible " for their
women kind: it is apparent that if responsibilities are
undertaken they are so only in consideration of
privileges in lieu. The day when women can invoke
the respoisibility, while denying the privilege, draws to
a close after a brief noon. It is becoming clearer what,
in the way of freedom of activity, women must needs
renounce if they proceed with the one species of feminist
propaganda, i.e., unrestricted entry into the labour
markets, payment of wives, and the like; and equally
clear, on the other hand, what responsibilities they must
be prepared to take on their own shoulders if they press
the opposing feminist shibboleths: "free" love, equal
claims to divorce, and so on, is becoming clear. The two
brands of the propaganda, though springing from the
one source, are heading in opposite directions ; but
neither is aimless. One is the instinct towards the
emoluments and conferred status which goes with
"property": the other is towards the self -responsi-
bilities of "freedom" which, being interpreted in its
only useful sense, means "power." The question is
whether women have the power, the genuine self-supply-
ing power, and not the bogus counterfeit of conferred
power. Because, if they have not, by assuming heavy
and unaccustomed responsibilities, their ambitions are
leading them towards disaster, just as inevitably as
every Englishman believes that German ambitions,
backed by over-rated powers, are leading their nation to
disaster. For instance, every form of self-responsible
power demands — not last, but first — capable physical
self-defence. One might venture to say it would be
impossible to find in these islands any " advanced"
woman who has not felt herself made into something of
a fool by the unequivocal evidence as to the position of
women presented by the war — not merely in the coun-
tries actually devastated by the war — but here in
England. They find that they may busy themselves
with efforts to assist their less "protected" sisters
towards maintenance: they may form an admiring
audience: they may have the honour of being allowed to
share in their country's defence by dint of knitting
socks: or "serve," as one ungallant soldier put it, by
providing ono of the "horrors of war" as a Red Cross
Nurse. In the war-area itself, they form part, along
with the rest of the property, of the spoils of the con-
quered. One cannot easily refrain from the inference
that, though they have weakened the pull of the old-
womanly competence, the "advanced women" have
done very little in the way of furnishing the necessary
foundations for its successor.
Whichever path one takes in considering this question
of womanly complementariness or secondariness, if one
so chooses to call it, always the same conclusion is
arrived at: an effectual assertion of physical force is the
first essential to any successful digression from the
normal womanly protected sphere. It is a blunt fact,
with a none too attractive sound, and there will be few
women who will care to give voice to it: which silence,
by the way, is more telling evidence of the amount of
distance which the "movement" has travelled than
fifty years of platform oratory. Poor Mrs. Pankhurst,
to her bewilderment, found herself driven irresistibly
against the fact only to gib at it each time she came up
with it. She could not avoid it, still less could she go
through with it. "Militancy" in its infancy and
"Militancy" now, in its decrepitude, are the transla-
tions into practical effect of her realisation of and her
revolt from it.
Whether the "revolting" women will ever move on
to the. point of acquiring the elements of self-defensive
and aggressive force depends on the extent to which the
ardour of ambition can survive the depressing effects of
the present too realistic presentation of their actual
position. In any case, the set of circumstance and
environment are against it. For it, there is nothing but
pride of temper; the same ferment, however, which has
been responsible for the rising of every subordinate race
and class. If Englishwomen elected to, there exists
nothing in themselves to prevent them from being as
good a fighting force as the Japanese, for instance: and
that woidd do to be getting along with. What does
prevent them is lack of desire, and therefore lack of
initiative; consequently there is no apparent necessity to
make a drive through that heavy inertia which the sub-
stantial triumphs of passive womanliness have fostered.
They are accustomed to win success almost solely
through well-utilised inertia, and the better they succeed
as "females," the more, encouraged they are to remain
inert. The spur of necessity, occasionally, will over-
come it ; but, lacking that, there is nothing to urge them
on, and everything to pull them back. Even status —
women's status — lies that way. Ninety-nine out of every
hundred women can better hope to improve their status
by looking to their marriage chances than by " carving
a career." Only a personal pride (out of the ordinary),
and intelligence, and the unique something which sets
straight for individual power, remains to count on.
Their possession is rare enough, and even when
possessed are to be exercised only if something quite as
vital to women can be fitted in alongside. In exchang-
ing the old competence for the new, no women can
afford to forego that end which was the main objective
of the old competence, and which this earlier proved so
superlatively successful in attaining.
36+
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
VIEWS AND COMMENTS.
LET us rid our mind nf cant" : in which sentiment
witness the hustle of the popular philosopher.
Why rid ourselves of cant ? Who knows any-
thing about its uses ? May not cant be a necessary
utility like clothing: why, then, should we allow our-
selves to be hustled into casting it off merely to live up
to the exigencies of dramatic oratory 1 Rather let us dis-
sect: the one safe course to follow in doubling popular
heroics back upon popular philosophy. 77. chord is to
sing: '" runt is to make — anything you please — into a
song. The difference between the two is that each
directs its emphasis towards a particular and different
stage of the vocal process. To chant, i.e., to sing, is to
have regard to the actual execution of the arranged har-
mony. To cant, i.e., the making of a song, concerns
itself with the process antecedent to the singing : it is
concerned with the construction of the song. Joy in the
actual performance is the main attraction of the chant,
and the substance and arrangement of the song sub-
serves that. In canting the pleasure is in the substance
and arrangement (selective interpretation !) and it is
this which the pleasure of canting subserves. The dif-
ference between our local " philharmonic" letting itself
go on the Hallelujah chorus and Mr. Lloyd George or
any other statesman letting themselves go on the causes
of the war can be rendered down to this difference.
* * * *
No one dreams of saying "let us rid ourselves of
song!" Why then the difference in acquiescence when
one says, "let us rid ourselves of song-making! " It is
due to a recognition of the reversal in motive : it is due
to suspicion : in a song the- words are intended to
heighten and increase the pleasure of the singing: in
cant, the pleasure of singing is to further and enforce
the substance embodied in the words. In the song the
expression of emotion is the end. In cant the emotion
embodied in the expression is utilised to serve the inte-
rests embodied in the words : with intent of making that
interest paramount over all other interests. To heighten
the importance of a matter by emphasis and reiteration
is, in fact, just what the man in the street has always
meant when he observed that someone is '"making a
song" about a matter. "Making a song" is a design
to make one aspect of an affair all-absorbing by means
of repetition, lilt, rhyme, rhythm : but above all by
repetition. The song and cant (motives apart) are
identical in this. Consider the common church anthem
as an instance : a tag is taken : it is told once or twenty
times over in the treble : it is told over again in the bass,
and again and yet again in the tenor and contralto: then
in twos, then the quartette, then the full chorus: a most
pleasurable diversion altogether.' And one does not
forget that tag in a hurry: it " runs in the head " to the
exclusion of all other tags, for days. Cant does the
same thing, and is intended to. Atrocities, German
atrocities, more atrocities, always atrocities, always
German, bombs, cathedral-fronts, stained glass, women,
prisoners, and so on without end. Cant! The jour-
nalists and mob-orators have considered it necessary to
"make a song" about these things in order to impress
permanently on the British mind the connection between
atrocious deeds and a German. Evidently they con-
sider it necessary in order to keep English rage up to the
fighting point. Others may think it unnecessary, and
only a very poor compliment to boot, but that for the
present is a matter of opinion. One might, neverthe-
less, point out that with all songs at a certain stage
there arises such a phenomenon as surfeit, when revul-
sion does the work of poetic justice and corrects the
balance. We seem to be Hearing it! Journalists and
orators might note.
* * * *
But to rid ourselves of cant, how can we ? And why
should we ? We can try to be clever at canting and not
to allow a possibly useful weapon to be turned to our
own disadvantage. Because cant is not the attribute of
anyone in particular : everybody cants. Any particular
man's cant is his emphasis of his own point of view,
which inevitably he seeks to press home by all the
agencies within his power, and of which words have
become the chief. Consequently, it is open to everyone
to accuse any rival of canting. The Kaiser with his
deity cants like chanticler : but he is lost besides our
shrill roosters at home. The essence of cant is to fill
the bill so completely and continuously with the state-
ment of one's own case that the other side's case fails to
reach the ear of the populace. We English have no
"case" in Germany and Germany has no "case" here.
In each country, however, there should be those in
power who recognise the scope of cant: that it is only a
preliminary defence. They assuredly should have heard
to the last syllable the whole of their opponent's case in
order to gauge the force of egoistic temper behind the
force that will further it. It is essential to know the
temper of the opposition they will be called upon to
meet. Cant is not out of place with the multitude, if it
were, it would not go down so well. In truth, it keeps
them in good temper with themselves : but it would be
fraught with the direst effects if it had influence with
those who have to take stock and make plans. For the
"masses" of the stout-heart but unbraced intelligence
cant evolves a "battle-cry." It gives consistency to a
possibly doubtful faith in the efficacy of the sword: it
warms and expands the spirit like an intoxicant: those
who fear to lose a point for hocus-pocus by using
plain English would say it strengthened the morale.
Undoubtedly the war-whoop is cant's primitive and
undeveloped ancestor, as the ear-splitting detonation of
the big guns is its modern offspring. The intent of both
is to put the foe to confusion by bluster to one's own
advantage. There is no cause for alarm, therefore, in
that the parsonic hosts are placing their pulpits in the
market-place, and filling them with cantatists of all
orders, exhorting us to mend any small rent which we
may have tolerated in our robes of thick British cant.
This vigorous species with the bell-like tones may con-
tinue to assault the heavens, unique as ever in its lack
of guile, too stupid and unselfconscious to be insincere.
It wdl serve if, in the prosecution of their solid business,
men are able to put cant in its proper place, and if in
national affairs those who are charged with responsi-
bility know at what point its good uses end :
limited to fortify one's own spirits, to depressing
one's opponents, to winning the applause of the on-
lookers, and— above all — furnishing our spiritless shib-
boleths with their natural antidote. In the timid, if
piping times of peace, men having created a verbal
" Wrong " which they hold to have an existence inde-
pendent of the weakening of Might, i.e., of Spirit, it
behoves them that at times when at all costs that error
must be corrected they shall have at hand always a
verbal means of escape. Cant enables them to dodge
the "Wrong" label and holds it firmly affixed to the
brows of their opponents. They cant themselves into
the right by making a song about it: incidentally
drowning for their own side the sound of their oppo-
nent's cant, which, be assured, is engaged in the same
heartening business in its own behalf. So cant remains
a thing of words always, an affair intended for the
gallery: useful in its sphere. Its baleful effects begin
when it is taken for something fundamental: when it
convinces its victims that it seriously affects the issue.
When men get into the temper which can sing:
" For Right is Right, since God is God,
And Right the day must win,"
cant looks likely to be dangerous. Men are so liable to
overlook the subtlety of such a sentiment. "Right"
always, as the hymn says, wins the day: that is, Might
wins it, and having won it, is automatically invested
with its new title of Right. Cant tends to antedate the
birth-hour of Right: that is why it proves a snare if
its influence spreads into the quarters that matter: into
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
365
the initiatory quarters. Cant may not, with impunity,
penetrate into serious business. There men must look
facts squarely in the face if they are to prevent being
hit in the face by them. The rough-and-ready effects of
cant are out of order here, where success and precise
observation belong to each other. In business as in
affairs of state, of course, it is quite in the way to
attempt to confuse one's rival with cant, if one can
safely; but in reviewing ones own case for serious
purposes, no.
* * * *
How far, therefore, men who are seeking to direct
affairs on a large scale can manage to utilise the
potentialities of cant, and yet keep themselves un-
spotted from it, becomes a nice question. Certainly by
a sort of horse-sense even with the crowd, the man who
has least to say carries most weight: certainly with the
weighty: but there appears to be no end of good fun in
exercising one's power to send thrills down the spines of
audiences of thousands by audacious tickling of their
vanity: in oratory that is, which orators a bit shame-
facedly, it must, be confessed, have railed the exercising
of a sense of power. Yet there is always a certain feel-
ing of contempt for it: a feeling of the second-rate, and
should be left for those "on the climb." Probably it
is the uneasy realisation that out of an audience of ten
thousand there will be live men who are chuckling under
their breath at the spectacle: the five who stand for
more than the remaining thousands. One cannot help
feeling that, if the itinerant Ministers, now on the rant,
had decided to forgo the exhibition of their eloquence,
Biitish prestige would have been none the worse, but
better rather, and more meriting the onlooker's respect.
* * # *
Mr. Lloyd George's flamboyant rhetoric about
" scraps of paper " (over which effort, by the way, " The
Times" gurgled a gleeful half-column of applause),
would have come with undiminished dignity only from'
parsons, ecstatic novelists, and journalists. Coming
from a responsible person it flecks Hie brilliance of feats
of arms with the dimness of unintelligent*. Yet from
beginning to end it is a triumph in the art of covering
up one's opponent's point: it is first-rate cant in fact,
glowing with the speaking, forming, and colour of the
picturesque. "Have you any Bank-notes'! What are
they? Scraps of paper! Made from rags! Tear them
up! Burn them!" subserves exquisitely the arranged
anti-climax that these have the "credit of the British
Empire behind them!" It is in the choice of the anti-
climax that the full artistry of cant is revealed: for docs
not the opponents' whole case turn upon the fact that it
is just the credit of the Empire that is being questioned?
If the Miijht of the British Kmpire failed to be re-
asserted on the spot the "credit of the Kmpire" would
be rapidly run down to the level of rags and scraps of
paper. Let a German government establish itself in
London, and Mr. George's enraptured audience will
swiftly apprehend the connection between " armed
force" and "the credit of the Empire" — this or any
other.
* * * •*
"The Times." which on the eve of war was a valuable
national asset, is now disporting itself in ungainly
fashion trying to win the favours of the verbalist host
whose influence it was mainly instrumental in over-
coming two months ago. One must see in it another of
the multitudinous uses of cant it is to be supposed !
Having broken the pacifist temper from its moorings in
the first place, it seeks now by a gentle impersonal
chiding of pacifism subtly combined with encourage-
ment and judicious personal flattery of pacifists, to
manoeuvre them past the impending danger of making
an outcry for an early peace. In keeping with its
present tactics, it has delivered itself afresh on the
" meaning of the war." The war is, it says, " when
reduced to its simplest expression — a struggle between
false and true standards of life." It piously proceeds,
"We stand for a principle that no might can, in the long
run, maintain itself, unless it be founded on some moral
law." The " some " is delicious: it is so safe: so safe
that the leader-writer concludes that here he can do no
better than leave it. If he developed his point he needs
would require to enlarge on the " ethical law," and
doubtless he has a strong premonition that, when
formulated, his ethical law would bluntly run " Might
is right." At least we gather as much when a little
further on he plaintively— or is it satirically— delii'ers
himself thus: " The people of this country have hitherto
lived in the touching faith that, sooner or later, it is
truth that tells. They have not only neglected," . . .
etc., etc. — neglected, that is, to keep their powder
dry by matching German "News" agencies with
similar British "News" agencies, and out of his
own text it is easy to double back on the pious sentiment
of his first paragraph, and adapt its phrases to fit the
model of "Ye perfect English." " Prussianised
Germany," he. says, " has staked her existence upon the
claim that might is right, with the corollary that
Prussian might gives the measure of others' right."
Adapted, this would run, " England has had,
reluctantly, and in spite, of mumbo-jumbo, to confess
that her 'right' to existence as foremost nation is
staked upon her ability to refurnish the ' might ' to
prove it. Having proved it, the corollary follows that
English might will give the measure of others right."
It is a curious historical phenomenon to find two para-
mount nations with such completely identical character-
istics. In their ambitions, their cant, they arc one.
Only the difference in their Might will define and divide
them. # # * *
There are arguments used, however, which it would
perhaps be paying too great a compliment to describe
as cant. They are too obviously just erroneous observa-
tions. If one said that two and two made three, it
would not bo cant: but just a silly mistake. Of such is
the orators' argument that we oppose " material force "
with "spiritual might." All directed forces are the
outcome of the spiritual: that is, animated by the living
spirit. A gun, an airship, all the material appur-
tenances of war are aggressive evidence that spirit has
been previously at work. The army of the veriest
tyrant is all composed of the workings of mastering
spirit. It is not the material which has made and makes
them formidable, but spirit. Those who look con-
temptously on the material forces of armies, and call
them material, have the eyes which see not. A big
dream, shared and toiled for by millions, is embodied
in those devised means of aggression. The Might of a
force is indeed the measure of the amount of spirit, just
as submission and unwilling preparations are the
measure of the lack of it. If we are subdued by the
German host it will be because their spirit has been
greater than our own. It is because of the great spirit
of the German that he animates material with-which to
measure himself against the world. It is a great-souled
thing to do: not lightly to be undertaken because not
lightly to be abandoned. The v/orTd should see to that:
as it will if it has the spirit. Which is why talk of
peace, before events have revealed unmistakably the
victors and the conquered is childish. To challenge the
world to a test of might is not a matter to be regarded
airily, but a matter of life and death: as much so to the
nation as to the individual. To know- that this is so, is
to hold the automatic check on irresponsibility and fool-
hardiness. Might is not mocked: it is the one sphere
w r here the genuine is winnowed from the sham.
* * * *
Nearer to the spirit of good cant is the surmise of the
orator that the struggle is to espouse the " ideals of
freedom against the oppression of the Iron Heel " — Iron
Heel presumably meaning, "armed force." A politician,
or any professional deceiver can always count on doinc
good cant-business if he flourishes the word "freedom"
well enough. That is because there is an utter lack of
comprehension as to the meaning of the word "free."
The word "free," in fact, charming as to sound as it is,
for explicitness is a word too many: it is the redundancy
responsible for abortive attempts without number in
366
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
social aspirations. The "free"' and the "powerful"
are one. When one has the power to encompass a certain
end, one is "free" to do it: not before. To be free
means no more than that— to be powerful in any par-
ticular direction specified: but the aspect which needs
engraving on the human consciousness is that it means
no less: the spurious "freedoms" — "liberties"
graciously allowed, without the po«W to enforce them if
withheld: all that long list of "rights " held by power-
less, enfranchised masses: these are the poor things, the
winning of which makes the history of centuries: they
are the liberties of sheep, of domestic beasts of burden:
they have little or nothing to do with free men — men of
power— capable of self-defence, forces to be- reckoned
with.
D. M.
FIGHTING PARIS.
August 18. — Fine, not too warm, perfect soldiers'
weather. News in the evening that the Kronprinz is
wounded.
August 19.— The " Echo de Faris" describes the land-
ing of British troops in France, presumably at Dieppe, as
1 heard a lady the other day say that her son had been
sent to Rouen to act as interpreter between the French
and English officers there. This was a sight I would
have given much to witness. It appears sign-posts in
English have been put along the soldiers' route, as also
notice-boards saying the rule of the road in France is
to keep to the right. No lists of killed or wounded in
the French troops are published, and as the military
movements are kept quite dark the war, now the
mobilisation is over, seems a long way off. T note an
overflow of sentimentality in the French papers, for
which I suppose allowance must be made under the
circumstances. Thus 1 read in one the following
quotation from a soldier's letter to his family: "Can
you believe that the motor 'bus which brought our food
supplies was precisely one of our brave, one of Our
excellent and dear Madeline-Bastille's!" War will
induce people to use terms of endearment of a motor
'bus. Have been gathering fruit and making jam these
last few days. We hear that Dr. P. is with his ambulance
corps at Liege, and says there are very few wounded
among the French, and in his regiment only one, while
the German wounded arc numerous. For the time being
the French wounded are sent South, to Orange. Ncvers,
etc., when the cases permit transport. The wounds are
chiefly in the legs. Mr. S. this evening was remarking
on the quiet and emptiness of Paris. He counted four
vehicles in the Avenue dc 1' Opera from one end to the
other.
August 20. Charming, spring-like, not too warm
weather. " An article in the Matin describes the arrival
of British troops at Dunkirk. What a contrast there is
in the tone adopted by the journalists in regard to every-
thing British now to what it was, say, during the Trans-
vaal war or Faehoda period ! T wonder what M. Willette
thinks of it] Now everything English is praised, and
the very matters which in those days would at least
have been laughed at are admired. So much sweetness
between two countries has never been seen. T quote
this from the article in the Mafia: " The methodical way
in which they landed and took each his place was typical
of our allies' orderly genius, that marvellous gift for
organisation characterising the English. The men are.
besides, surprisingly youthful and sturdy, and to this
they add the calm and reflectiveness typical of the
race. . . . And the ' Tommies' ' conduct is faultless."
The way a British si.ldier walks, eats and drinks, his
uniform, everything about him is a subject for admira-
tion ; ten years ago he often inspired scorn and ridicule.
Such is the world. The same issue of the Matin contains
caricatures of German types. And never was the hatred
keener, the contempt bitterer for the Germans than it is
now. Surely not in 1870. They are invariably called
savages, ruffians, and not by street-boys and newspaper
scribblers merely but by men like Banes de Mun. Not
a German will be able to set foot in France or Belgium
I should think for the next ten years. The gentle young
man from Liege said to me as I ventured to doubt the
'atrocities" attributed to them: 'Madame, a'eri viai,
ce sent des barbares ; il ne faut pas avoir pitie d'eux "
with great and indignant emphasis. It remains in-
credible that they shoot women under the eyes of their
husbands," children in the presence of their parents,
civilians before their wives, the old and defenceless, the
wounded, the ambulance corps ; or that they have their
columns preceded by native women and children, and
put on the uniforms of dead British soldiers as the
papers report daily. If this were true the battle would
not be on equal terms, and would become a chastise-
ment and lose, therefore, in heroism. It is better to
esteem one's enemy, regardless as to whether or not he
really deserves it; better to over-esteem than to
over-despise him. This inclination to be too con-
temptuous of the enemy is the only error I find to
criticise in the French attitude at present. It is to be
supposed that it has not spread to the army where
contact with realities will dispel preconceived notions.
I have been reading the first book I have looked at for
weeks — Le Retain- dans la Xuit, by Martial Pieehaud.
H. S. C. has just come in with a paper announcing the
death of the Pope. The eanutrt, whose cries had brought
him out, observed on selling it him that all right-minded
people put their flags half-mast! I do not remember
whether I have mentioned that flags hang from all
windows, or at least a great many, and it is said that
the sight of them caused great surprise in the German
prisoners passing through the city for, having been told
it was in flames, they little expected such festive mani-
festations. The papers say the municipal council of
Paris is changing the name of the Rue d'Allernagne to
Rue Jean Jaures. Yet, if this socialist deputy had had
his way the Rue d'Allernagne would not only have
remained so in name but might have become so in fact.
This is sentimentality at :ts most inane. It is the same
spirit for stupidity is international — that bothers itself
about a motto for London. I am astonished by the
stoicism of the people, a stoicism due partly to ignorance
of the effects of events they cannot realise, partly to
fatalism, partly to their immunity from all calamities.
A little hunchback sempstress I employ has taken her
nice-looking young husband's mobilisation very quietly,
and what seems to have struck her most is that it took
place almost at the same hour as that of her brother-in-
law. Our maid tells us quite simply she has a sister
whose husband has also gone, leaving her with five
children, and dependent on the one franc a day allotted
to her plus 50c. a head for each child. In a paper I
read about a wounded soldier who, having taken a
German cavalry man's boot as souvenir, observed that
In- hoped to be cured quickly so as to be able to go and
fetch the other, to have the pair.
Aur.rsT 21.— This morning we were awakened by gun-
practice. Mulhouse is re-ocenpied by the French, and
twenty-four German guns have been taken. A flood of
"copy" will be made out of the war at its conclusion.
Ten of the editorial and contributing staff of one review-
alone are in active service. Among these I note the
name of M. Felicien Fagus who, in reply to an inquiry
made on the subject, gave the following epigrammatic
definition of the qualities constituting a good poem:
"A good poem," said he, "is the solution of a problem
m mechanics.'' It cannot be said that we have suffered
any privations up to now. Prices a-e as low as at usual
times, if not lower, and only here and there have certain
supplies gone out. The telegrams we receive bear the
mention " vise." The Liebig company finds it necessary
to publish that it is an English firm. This shows how-
German trade will be affected by the war.
August 22.— The Germans are occupying Brussels.
The sentinel on the bridge here has drawn a caricature
of the Kaiser on his box representing that gentleman's
helmeted head impaled on the points of bayonets rising
out of the earth's globe, and has written underneath:
"L Assassin sur des epines " (on thorns). In front of
a locomotive I saw a picture framed in triumphal
October 1, 191-i
THE EGOIST
367
greenery representing a hog's head with the Kaiser's
famous moustaches on a dish, while the legend under-
neath was a parody of an advertisement of certain
culinary preparations. At the V.'s I hear the poet G.
C. C. was at the Belgian frontier when last heard from,
and had sent some verse descriptive of his camp-life
which appeared in last evening's " Intransigeant." At
the publisher G. C.'s, where The Egoist's bill hangs in a
conspicuous position on the door, I am shown a letter
to his wife from one of the clerks, who is within gun-
range, and which appeared in a noon paper to-day.
Someone tells me that General Joffre, the most taciturn
of men, has been smiling during the last few days, than
which nothing could be a more hopeful sign. A few
days ago he had, as I was told, telegraphed to his wife
that all was well. Conveyances still slow and crowded.
Charming weather. A letter came this morning— four
days on the way— from the painter A. ,1., who is with his
regiment, and is disappointed that medical inspection
has precluded him from the lighting ranks.
August 23. — I was shown this morning the following
letter from a good peasant woman in an Eastern
province. It gives a picturesque account of the effects
of the war on country life. Except for u few necessary
commas I have preserved the original punctuation: —
"Dear Neiuhbouk,
"Aren't you ever coming hack? Here the streets
are deserted; there are no men (that is why we want
you like the Messiah), no horses, no carriages; the only
life :s supplied by the small boys and the women going
every evening at six to the soup kitchen, one portion for
each of them and each child, plus the 1 fr. 25 allotted to
each soldier's wife, and 50c. to each of the children.
The Maison familial?, has been transformed into a Red
Cross ambulance with Mme. O. as secretary; Mile. G.
treasurer, M. D. chemist, etc. A subscription was raised
here; these ladies and myself each gave 5fr. ; C, 300fr. ;
J., 50fr., etc. M. J. only sells his bread against cash;
an old odd-man and E., who has not left yet, bake;
there is no fancy bread made any longer, and the most
particular don't complain. We have given your plums
to Mr. J. to dry, for your garden is full of them. There
are many greengages at Mr. J.'s, as also in our garden.
We know nothing, or almost nothing; nows from soldiers
is so rare, and anxiety is written on the mothers' faces;
Catherine K. and Mme. P. are withering with anguish;
Mine. J. is often out of sorts, as to Mile. F. she is quite
well and trotting about everywhere. If you were here
you would certainly be doing the police, four hours now
and again at the entrance to the wood to stop all the
automobiles, for every driver has to show his papers.
And then there is a Civic Guard, to which you would
surely belong. Mr. V. has been named secretary to the
Mairie by the Council, and does his task dutifully.
Yesterday, the 15th, their sister, who died without an
agony, was buried ; she was carried to B. ; a car had
been asked of J., a carriage of R., and on Friday there
was requisition, the waggons being examined at V.
Saturday at 8 o'clock. Imagine the excitement; fortu-
nately one funeral conveyance was found at R., and all
the troubles caused by the war persecuted us; no men
to carry, etc., etc.
"The courage of all the younger women, many of
whom are future mothers, is admirable in its stoicism ;
Nadine has returned to her sister-in-law at R. until she
has her little one. . . . What mourning there will be
afterwards; Marie C. is very courageous. M. H. is at
the fort at V. ; the harvests arc going on alright in spite
of the lack of horses ; there are seven at the farm and
three at H. 's; the cows are requisitioned the first day.
Good-bye to our nice cafe au lait. . . . When you come
back you will do well to bring a netfull of supplies, for
there is nothing at the stores here ; the ' Economiquc '
does not even open its shutters. The baker P. has left,
and it is Pere V. who bakes; all cash. Amedee looks
after Mme. C. and the maison J. The front of the old
house has been redone up; the horse is at the wars.
M. J. was always turning over in his motor; but for the
last week interdiction. I am keeping ou my workmen,
as is also Mr. R., after which . . . joy or sadness, God
alone knows, shall we pick our grapes; another question.
. . . Mile. F. has given old linen for the wounded, but I
am wondering where competent nurses will be found.
" Mass is said at eight o'clock each Sunday, and many
people go ; we all come back pious. The ladies P. often
go to Low Mass. I am in the drawing-room waiting for
Mile. F., who has been to her friend for news, and
Mr. T. and we embrace you (on paper) in chorus.
' P. S. — The nephew Rene came to say good-bye, and
now there is no news of him any more than from the
other soldiers; lie looked very well. C, after nursing
her sister-in-law a fortnight at R. , has come back to us.
M. U. has come but will not stay; he prefers Paris,
where he has his habits, he says, more news and more
papers. Suzcttc and her son (or daughter) are well ; as
liver is difficult to find we give her milk."
This letter took a week to reach the capital. This
evening we had our usual aeroplane, apparently doing
scout- work. An incessant procession of cars carrying por-
tions of flying machine.-; come driving up our roads on
their way to the military aviation centre at Chalais.
To-night's paper refers to a great battle in Belgium.
One has the greatest pains to accustom oneself to the
idea. And the Germans arc on the direct road to Paris.
Things have never seemed so serious since Sunday three,
weeks ago — the first, mobilisation day. Someone had
been advertising for a lost sheep dog: "Perdu, Berger
allemaud." Underneath, a street urchin had scrawled,
"II a fui." I noticed the Kaiser's will is no longer sold
in the streets. These sort of pleasantries arc, indeed,
not tamely. It is quaint of the wounded French soldiers
to say that the Germans do not aim well.
August 24. — The Abbe Wetterle, the Alsatian ex-
Deputy at the Reichstag, writes as follows in to-day's
"Echodc Paris":—
"It was a great mistake on the part of Jaures to
have imagined that the proletariat on the other side
of the Rhine had resisted Pan-German pressure. The
German workman knows that if the army increases
the national territory his custom is increased, his posi-
tion therefore ameliorated and his wages higher. He
is, therefore, as militarist, as are the middle-classes.
At the time of the bill for the last budget, the Socialist
representatives made a purely formal opposition to the
enormous increase in the army contingencies, then
voted like one man for the one thousand million of
extraordinary taxes permitting the realisation of this
important reform. And why did they do so '( Because
they knew that if they did not their labour electors
would desert them."
In this article the Abbe Wetterle concludes that the
war was favoured by the people of Germany while really
withheld as long as possible by the Emperor, whom the
" Deutsches Tages Zeitung " called for his genuine
pacifist tendencies, at the time of the Agadir crisis,
"Wilhelm der Furchtsame." The sky has cleared— the
sky of heaven — and the weather is again very hot. yes-
terday's news of a battle in Belgium confirmed by to-
day's papers. We have had no letters of any kind for
sonic days and one feels very isolated. I am writing in
the garden in the most delicious temperature. There
are roses still on our rose trees, and hees are humming
around me. Except for these the silence is only inter-
rupted by the motors running to and from the aviation
camp at Chalais, and that dog which howled so just
before the mobilisation and again before the declara-
tion of war with Germany has started its moans again
to-day when the most serious news since that time
reaches us. Nature, meanwhile, is at its most exquisite,
and one's senses do not suffice to appreciate it. This
evening the postman's ring, not having been heard for
three days, caused excitement. It brought three cards
all at once from Switzerland. The cards received bear
no French postmark, but the Swiss stamp is dated the
20th in one case and 21st in the two others. N.'s card
is obviously written in view of censorship and gives
no news of Germany, although she is certainly informed.
T. L. F. writes, "I say nothing here that may cause
this card to be withheld." It is to he observed that
the three correspondents use postcards.
368
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
August 25.— From last nights "Liberie": "After
having withstood the German guns to the end, the
Commandant Nameche, head of the fort at Chaudfon-
taine around Liege, set fire to the powder and exploded
the fort, burying himself in its ruins."
The Germans are, it appears, terrified by the French
African troops. At Dijon, the other day, a train-load
of prisoners were very much alarmed at sight of some
nigger soldiers who had just arrived from Algeria and
who, having heard there were some of the enemy to be
seen at the station, scrambled on the carriages to ob-
tain a view of them. Their grinning faces caused the
Germans to crawl under the benches and to cry for
mercy and the officers had all they could do to get the
black men back into their places and discourage their
curiosity. This fear of native troops among the Ger-
mans is well known, and remembering it, a whole com-
pany, comprised chiefly of Parisians, got the idea to
blacken their faces with boot-blacking and to attack
the enemy with wild shrieks. " The effect," said one
of them, on explaining the stains on his face, which
the doctor at the hospital had difficulty in diagnosing,
"was simply prodigious." Perhaps, too, it is easier to
die in minstrel disguise. News of slight defeats at the
front. To town by tram. Find some of the metro
lines stopped, so have to take slow and crowded trams.
Long waits. Saw an agent give warning to a hawker
for crying "latest news" and another stop some men
to examine their papers. Said good-bye to J., who is
being repatriated to Russia on a French cruiser from
Marseilles. The papers this evening contradict the
morning's news that Namur had fallen, but confirm that
of German incursions into French territory Lille and
Tourcoing way. A man said to me this evening, "In
our offices 24 out of 60 employes remain." Our maid
showed me a letter she had just received from her
"young man," who is at a military hospital in the
south. The envelope had been neatly slit open and stuck
together again with a piece of stamp-paper. Correspon-
dence from England and Switzerland. The " Intran-
sigeant" says, "The English soldier have been 'admir-
able' under fire." The soldiers at Saint Cloud station
had adorned it with triumphal arches, made of greenery
and flags and pictures, representing the cock victorious
over the eagle, and similar themes. It was curious to
see the soldiers on the line gathered round the dinner-
table lighted by a shaded lamp like bourgeois on a
summer night in their banlieu garden.
August 26. — We learn the Cabinet has been changed.
M. Millerand becomes Minister of War, and this ap-
pointment increases our confidence. Altogether a
Cabinet of picked men. We are not surprised, for
within the last few days the papers had quite evi-
dently got out of hand ; moreover, several directed
transparent criticisms at the Minister of War in power
at the time of the retreat from Alsace, so atrociously
disappointing for the Alsatians, will very likely also
have caused this change. The papers make very en-
thusiastic comments on Lord Kitchener's speech before
the House of Lords. A writer in some paper has had
the happy idea to suggest the re-opening of the Paris
theatres. This absurd proposal shows how indis-
pensable the theatre is to the average Parisian. Mean-
while trainloads of wounded are being brought from the
front. I have been reading " Le Hasards de la
Guerre." by Jean Variot (George Cres et Cie.). a not
inappropriate way of occupying one's thoughts, as the
title may suggest. But apart from the description of
a pilgrimage to some famous battlefields, to Waterloo,
the Beresina Pass, and so on, concluding with a sojourn
of a few pages with the Legion Etrangere in Morocco,
the book deals but little with warfare. Considering our
re-awakened interest in Alsace-Lorraine the author
might have dwelt longer on the peculiarities of that
pathetically divided country, whose features he, as an
Alsatian, alludes to with lingering and sympathetic
melancholy. If his present share in the struggle for it
spares him he will no doubt gratify the general
curiosity by giving us a more complete view of the
idiosyncrasies to which its sad and exceptional fate have
given rise, for it is veiy difficult for an outsider to grasp
the limitations of national feeding — so terribly tried in
the last half-century — among this people. Their
mingled customs, too, partly German, partly French,
often purely autochthonous, their lore, their predilection
for military and often, even, for naval service — strange
to say— afford occasion for the most promising investiga-
tion. Last night's "Temps" described how a French
soldier picked up his shot-off arm, taking it away with
him from the battlefield to prevent the Germans getting
it ! The few advertisements contained in the papers are
all distressing. Here is one: " The young men who were
at Bensheim, at Professor Fritzmann's, are requested,
if they are back in France, to be so good as to give news
of her son, about whom she knows nothing, to
.Mine. Gaillard, 3 Ave. Ledru Rollin, Montpellier."
August 28. — Letters from England four days old. I
like the remark I find in a paper referring to
Mme. Caillaux's organisation of an ambulance. " .She
had better," writes the journalist, "go to the front,
seeing what a good shot she is." We hear our friend,
Dr. de N., is with his ambulance at Corbeil, "charmed
with his fate and die happiest of men." We met Mr.
P. in Paris to-day. He, like so many others of his
period, has been sent back home from his regiment as
the men are too numerous. A deficit of 20 per cent, had
been expected, and it proves to be less than 1 per cent.
He says equipment was not lacking in his corps.
August 29.— The censorship exercised by the new
Minister is evidently very severe, for news is again of
the scarcest. We are simply told we maintain our
positions at the frontier. Dr. P. has again written home
from Belgium ; he says the ambulance doctors have
worked twenty-four hours at a stretch, and he among
other doctors has been called by the Germans to attend
their wounded, their own medical staff being over-
whelmed. There will be no trains on the Nord line for
travellers to-morrow, we hear. There is some alarm
about the possibility of the Germans coming to Paris
after all, notably among foreigners and the lower classes.
The few of the former who remain are packing up in
view of flight. The Chartrenx monks have returned to
their country— whence they were exiled— to take up
service.
August 30. — The Germans have been, or are, at La
Forte, a fortified town 25 k. from Laon. How well I
remember sitting on the beautiful ramparts of Laon last
year with H. S. C. and Dr. de N., and the former
observing, with reference to the great stretch of fertile,
open country at our feet, that here the fate of France
would be decided at the next clash with Germany. To
market. This locality is quite deserted. Hardly any-
one at the market, and little business done. M. 0., who
came to lunch, says Paris is in alarm, and at the market
I heard people talking of sudden departures. Some
friends leave for England ; M. O. goes to Normandy. A
lady has arrived here from Sedan saying every house
there has been burnt down, including her own, the
French having been obliged to bombard it during its
occupation by the Germans. What tragic episodes one
reads of: General de Castelnau saw his son killed undn
his eyes while he was commanding his men, but did not
allow the circumstance to interrupt his duties. General
Pau's son is wounded; the former is commander-in-chief
of the army operating in the East. Hot, very fine
weather to-day again. One cannot realise there is war
in the world. Letter from Mme. V. this morning saying
how thankful she is she has been given occupation at a
Red Cross hospital, occupation which consists mainly in
washing floors and windows out of charity ! The poet.
G. C. C, was in the North when last heard of, that is
in the midst of action. Card from T. L. F., the con-
finned socialist and pacifist, who deplores he is not
fighting, and hopes he will have a chance in Italy ! He
says our letter written to him in Switzerland a fo'rtnight
ago has only just reached him. The papers now often
contain blank spaces— information blotted out by the
censor at the last moment. Maurice Barres writes
heroically and optimistically each day in the " Echo de-
Pans." He expresses the utmost ' contempt for the
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
369
Germans, and to-day refers to them as "these eternal
pedants who like to play at being demons." Everyone
in this house a little downcast to-day.
Arui'ST 31.— The Germans are advancing from the
North, but being repulsed in Lorraine. A German
aeroplane flew over Paris yesterday, and its aviator
threw a few bombs about, killing a woman. Informa-
tion on this as on all matters scarce, and containing
blank lines. Panic in Paris apparent by the number of
people waiting again outside the grocer Polin's. The
fun persistently directed at the Germans, their thought,
literature, art, etc., in many of the papers (the " Temps"
excepted), especially in the " Matin," seems singularly
inappropriate; it will be time enough to laugh at them
after the victory. Bui, while their ambition to occupy
Paris is not far from being realised, this sarcasm is ill-
placed. I have just lighted upon a regrettable copy of
the "Matin" of ten days ago containing caricatures of
absurd-looking German officers. To Paris, where I learn
from serious sources (not in the street or in the popular
gossip, or in the papers which are quite devoid of news)
that the Germans are at C'ompiegne where the English
are too. Time will verify whether this is true. I am told,
also, that there is discord in the command. If the enemy
is at Compiegne this would be in agreement with their
whole plan of campaign— namely, to occupy Paris. I
was told also that the government was about to be
transferred to Orleans in view of removing to Bordeaux
later if necessary. I am assured the money at the
Banquc de France is safe. To M. O.'s to find she had
left in haste this morning. The S. V.'s are packing to
leave to-morrow. The terror of each is that he may
have to pay for the deeds of fianr-limirs. Both here and
in the city itself I have seen numbers of di-nii'-nagement
waggons, and taxis, cabs, hand-carts and every available
vehicle filled with luggage or furnitnre, while large
families troop by, each member carrying a bundle pro-
portioned to age and size. The men of the territorial
and reserve forces who were sent back a week or ten
days ago have been called out again. Thus M. P., whom
we met on Saturday, has returned to his regiment at
Blois. The young men who were to have begun their
service this year — the 1014 classe as it is called have also
been called out, so events agree with rumours. Another
significant circumstance was that Paris was without
lights last night. The effects of censorship can be very
quaint. Thus a noon paper announced a column of news
on the "Fighting in th?. North," but the column was
blank from beginning to end, and only the headline
remained. In future, says a new regulation, all head-
lines will be forbidden, and hawkers will not be allowed
to cry the names of the papers they sell. Letter from
Miss M. saying she leaves in two hours. Dr. S. tells me
it was impossible to gel. a taxi to-day, a sign that more
men have been called out, as also that what taxis there
are are quickly snapped up by fugitives. I had noticed
trams were rarer and very crowded. This morning 1
put away dress-suits and such clothes as we are not
likely to wear for a long time.
September 1.— The paper confirms the flight of
another (or the same) German aeroplane above Paris
yesterday. Two bombs were thrown, but no one (so
far as the news goes) was hurt. The paper also says
that the Germans are advancing on Paris, being on
the banks of the Oise. but no mention is made of their
being at Compiegne or as near as that. Card this morn-
ing from N., posted in Switzerland, on the 2Sth. B. is,
as I noticed this morning, absolutely deserted except for
waggons removing furniture, fugitives carrying bundles
and luggage, and the usual military motors. One motor
contained a Belgian officer. To Paris. The town is in
some panic and the station was besieged with fugitives,
and what taxis and cabs are to be seen are laden with
families and luggage. Everyone carries a bundle, bag.
or basket, and families are seen camping on the pave-
ment. They Bay 10,000 people tried to leave the Gare
iMontparnass-.- this morning. Called at Mile. O. B.'s,
then at a bank, where they refused to cash a cheque for
me (I had been under the impression that the renewal
of the moratorium permitted the cashing of cheques
dated previously to the mobilisation); tried to buy some
provisions at Potin's, but the waiting crowd was such
that I preferred to go elsewhere to another stores where
there was not a single customer and where there were
supplies in plenty, except salt, which I could not obtain,
being told that 50 kilos had been sold out in the morn-
ing, one kilo at a time. The rumours in Paris are that
three generals are under lock and key at the Cherchemidi
military prison— (as I write, the fourth aeroplane within
the. last half hour passes above our house ; first came a
monoplane at a good height from the Paris direction ;
some little time after, H. S. C. called me to hear some
rapid gun-shots; then in a few minutes a second mono-
plane appeared in the skies, also from Paris ; since
then two biplanes have made their appearance from the
opposite direction, the one steered left, the other right;
the two biplanes flew low, a sign they are French) —
Generals P., D., and a third, whose name I do not re-
member. Some say General P.. recently revoked for
having kept an order in his pocket for several days re-
questing him to send immediate reinforcements to
Charleroi, was cither shot or committed suicide.
General D. is accused of having attempted to take Mul-
housc with insufficient forces. It is reported (not yet in
the papers) that the government is about to be trans-
ferred to Lyon. I also heard that yesterday's German
aviator sent a bomb on Notre Dame. The information
the "Journal" had intended giving on the matter was
censored, as a long paragraph under the heading is left
blank. A lady in the train, on the return home, told
me there were wounded from Amiens at the station and
that she had spoken to them and found them in very
good spirits. I met a Polish lady at Mile. O. B.'s, who
had just, returned from the Baltic coast. The Russian
subjects who were taking the sea-baths there were
not gently dealt with but not very roughly either.
Though they had bought first or second-class tickets
they were all packed into fourth-class carriages and con-
veyed slowly and uncomfortably to the Danish frontier.
We have been laying in a few supplies to-day in view
of a bombardment — coal, paraffin, etc., in case fuel,
electric light and gas fail us, but it is very difficult to
make up one's mind as to how much to buy, and what.
So we have taken but very elementary precautions. I
am told that M. C, ex-Minister of Finance, is "Colonel-
Treasurer Paymaster" lo the forces. I heard also that
the mobilisation had been ordered at General J.'s
pressure, who had threatened M. Poincare, who was
desirous of putting it off for awhile, with immediate
resignation if it was delayed. Other people say M. V.
(a fifth aeroplane has come, though it is almost dark,
at a good height from the city direction and now steers
a different way from the others) wanted it to he
delayed. 1 have also heard that it was M. P. who had de-
cided and ordered the mobilisation. Dogs barked a
great deal last night, and are beginning again to-day.
The darkness has fallen suddenly with hardly any
twilight. All civilians were ordered out of Reims on
Sunday. Numerous train-loads of wounded pass daily
through Versailles. The French, the English, the
Belgian wouuded are "brave," in the French
journalist's language; the Germans deserve no epithet.
It was pathetic to-day to sec, shifted on side-lines,
numerous troop-trains still ornamented with branches
(in the window-opening of one was a little bunch of
withering flowers) showing caricatures of the Emperor
William, and the usual scrawl in chalk against the
official label. " Voiturc ii destination pour. . . ." with
Berlin added. Strange to see this with the enemy at
our very gates. There id a search-light on Mont
Valerien to-night.
Sf.i'Tember 2. — The paper confirms the German advance
on Paris and the presence of a Taubc over i'aris yester-
day afternoon Going out on some errands 1 meet with
fugitives in luggage-laden motors or waggons, according
to their fortune, on every hand. One lady sending tele-
grams off at the post office has a marmezet in a cage
This evening an aeroplane passed overhead again, and
again wc heard shots. Going out we found a number of
people massed on the railway bridge who said bombs
370
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
had been thrown out of it. The shots came from rifles
and from the guns on the Eiffel Tower. Trains with re-
cruits—all very young fellows, those who were to begin
their military service this autumn— have been passing
with vociferations through the stations all day. The
evening paper confirms the report I had heard privately
on Monday, namely, of fighting at Compiegne with the
English. A lady in a shop said she had heard that the
forest of Compiegne was on fire. The Government left
Paris this morning at 4 o'clock. Dr. S. tells us he saw
the bomb which was thrown from an aeroplane yester-
day afternoon and which fell in the Rue de Hanovre.
Card from a friend, who talks of going south on account
of the rumoured siege of Paris.
September 3. — What nights are ours ! Every now and
then one wakes up in a start reminding oneself that
the Germans are at our very threshold. A glorious
summer morning; swallows flit about, an exquisite still-
ness, broken only by the desperate shriek of passing
trains. Never was there such a summer as this ! The
" Echo de Paris" {now, for the first time, appearing on
a single sheet instead of the two it kept up while all
other papers had been reduced to one) announces the
departure of the Government for some unnamed pro-
vincial town. The latest war news is of the 1st, namely,
the engagements at Compiegne with the English. The
shouts of passing recruits reach us just, as on the first
days of the mobilisation. To market., where there are
any amount of supplies, but prices slightly raised.
Meet, waggons with poor emigrants from the outer forti-
fied zone, who have been given notice to leave their
homes, these being in danger and having to be
destroyed. The wealthier population takes flight, too,
but from choice. To Paris by boat— for there are no
passenger trains for Montparnasse to be relied upon —
provision hunting. Everything, or nearly everything, to
be obtained still and, with a few exceptions, at the
usual prices. Certain provisions, like salt and rice, are
generally doled out in small and limited quantities.
Charming but rather warm weather and the return home
by boat exceptionally beautiful in a golden, hazy
twilight. Such a summer as this I do not remember.
A most magnificent sight is provided by the numerous
barges at anchor lying in endless rows twelve deep and
occupying half the width of the river. Most of them
are Belgian and many carry straw, which is being slowly
unshipped. Dr. M. came to say good-bye, leaving on
his bicycle — (for trains arc not to be had except for
peop;e who took their tickets several days in advance) —
for his home, where he hopes to be enrolled as ambulance
doctor to some regiment. The establishment he con-
ducted has been closed, the patients have left. Thus the
smooth run of life is suddenly interrupted for each and
all. The evening paper describes the departure of the
Government and diplomatic corps for Bordeaus.
Bi-itish soldiers are to be seen about the town. The
Bourse was guarded by military this afternoon, I am
told, and papers and documents removed into waggons.
Ski-tember 4.— At half past two this morning we were
awakened— if one can say awakened, for who sleeps? —
rather, we started at the sound, muffled, distant but un-
mistakable, of firing guns. We first heard two separate
shots, and a little later several consecutive shots. Then
all fell back into stillness. How impressive was this
grim interruption of the most beautiful of moonlight
nights ! A British aeroplane, with British aviator,
patrolled the skies above Paris yesterday; we had seen
it but could not, of course, guess its nationality. No
post at all from abroad for some days— and no Egoist —
hut. one letter from a friend saying her husband is worry-
ing himself to death at not being able to make himself
useful. This strain, in presence of so uncertain a future,
will tell on many a mind and on many nerves. We left
our youth behind us, I fear, on August 1st, 1914.
Muriel Ciolkowska.
(To be continued.)
[Eiirai'UM - In the last i^sue (September loth; a printer's
error rendered menicite " monolith." Renders will, I hope,
have corrected this in their own minds.— M.C.]
THE SONGS OF MALDOROR.
By The Comte de Lautreamost.
Part I.
MAY it please heaven that the reader, emboldened
and for the moment as ferocious as what he
reads, will find without disorientation his abrupt
wild path across the desolate marshes of these sombre
poison-filled pages; for, unless he brings to his reading
a rigorous logic and a mental tension equal at least to
his distrust the mortal emanations of this book will
suck up his soul as water does sugar. It is not good
that everyone should read the pages which are to fol-
low ; a few only will taste this bitter fruit without
harm to themselves. Consequently, timid soul, before
penetrating further into such unexplored lands turn
your steps backwards and not forwards. Listen care-
fully to what I tell you: turn your steps backwards and
not forwards, like the eyes of a son who turns respect-
fully from the august contemplation of the maternal
face ; or rather, like an invisible angle of chilly cranes,
meditating deeply, which during the winter fly power-
fully across the silence, with extended wings, towards
a pre-determined point on the horizon, whence sud-
denly rushes a strange, strong wind, precursor of the
storm. The oldest crane, who forms by himself the
van-guard, seeing this, shakes his head like a reasonable
person, and consequently his beak also, which he
clatters, and is not pleased (I should not be pleased
either in his place), while his old neck, disfurnished of
plumes and contemporary with three generations of
cranes, trembles in irritated undulations, presaging the
storm which approaches nearer and nearer. After
having calmly examined every side with eyes full of
experience, prudently, the first (for he has the privilege
of showing his tail-feathers to the other cranes inferior
in intelligence) with his vigilant cry like that of a
melancholy sentinel, to repulse the common enemy, he
turns flexibly the point of the geometric figure (it is
perhaps a triangle, but no one can see the third side,
which these curious birds of passage form in space)
perhaps to larboard, perhaps to starboard, like a skilful
captain; and, maneuvering with wings which seem no
larger than a sparrow's, because he is not stupid, he
takes in this way another surer philosophic path.
* * *
Reader, perhaps you desire that I should invoke
hatred at the beginning of this work ! How do you
know that, you will not snuff up its red emanations
slowly and majestically with proud, large, thin nostrils,
bathed in innumerable delights, as much as you desire,
turning up your belly like a shark in the beautiful black
air as if you understood the importance of this act and
the no less importance of your legitimate appetite?
1 assure you they will delight the two ugly holes of
your hideous snout, O monster, if you set yourself
beforehand to inhale three thousand times the accursed
conscience of the Eternal ! Your nostrils, which will be
immeasurably dilated with ineffable content, with
immobile ecstasy, will ask nothing better from space,
being embalmed as if with perfumes and incense; for,
they will be glutted with complete happiness, like the
angels which dwell in the magnificence and in the peace
of the elegant heavens.
# * *
I will show you in a few lines how Maldoror was good
during his first years when he lived happily. He after-
wards perceived that he was born evil: extraordinary
fate.: He hid his character as much as he could; but
in the end because of this unnatural concentration the
blood rose to his head every day to such an extent that,
being unable to endure such a life, he threw himself
resolutely into a career of evil . . . SWC et atmosphere !
W ho would have thought it! When he kissed a little
rosy-faced child he would have liked to take off its
cheeks with a razor, and he would very often have done
it if Justice, with her long train of punishments, had
not prevented him each time. He was not a liar; he
admitted the truth and said that he was cruel. Human
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
371
beings, have you heard? He dares to repeat it with
this trembling pen ! Thus there is a power stronger
than will. . . . Curse ! Does the stone want to be
subject to the laws of weight? Impossible. Impossi-
ble if evil desired to be allied with good. That is what
I said before.
* * ■»
There are some who write to gain human applause
by means of the noble qualities of the heart invented
by the imagination or which they might possess. I
make my genius serve to paint the pleasures of cruelty !
Pleasures not transitory, not artificial, but pleasures
which began with man and will end with him. May
not genius be allied with cruelty in the secret resolu-
tions of Providence? or, because a man is cruel can he
not also be a genius? The proof will be seen in my
words j it rests with you to listen to me if you so
wish. . . . Excuse me, I thought my hair was standing
on end; but it is nothing, for with my hand I easily
replace it in its first position. He who sings here does
not pretend that his cavatinas are something unknown ;
on the contrary he natters himself that the high evil
thoughts of his hero are in all men.
* * *
During the whole of my life I have seen all these
thin-shouldered men without one exception commit
stupid acts, brutalise their kind and pervert souls by
all methods. They called the motives of their actions
"Glory." Seeing these things I wanted to laugh like
the others, but that strange imitation was impossible.
I took a pocket knife whose blade had a sharp edge
and I split my flesh at the place where the lips join.
For a moment I thought I had attained my end. I
looked in the mirror at this mouth gashed by my own
will. It was an error ! The blood which flowed abun-
dantly from the two wounds prevented me from seeing
whether it was really the laugh of others. But after
a few moments comparison I saw clearly that my laugh
did not resemble that of human beings ; that is to say,
I was not laughing. I have seen men with ugly heads
and terrible eyes buried in dark sockets, surpass the
hardness of rock, the rigidity of cast steel, the cruelty
of the shark, the insolence of youth, the mad fury of
criminals, the treachery of fhe hyprocrite, the most
extraordinary comedians, the power of a priest's
character, and the most outwardly secret beings, the
coldest in the planets and in heaven ; leave the moralists
to discover their hearts and bring down upon them the
implacable anger from on high. I have seen them
all together, sometimes the most robust fist directed
against heaven like that of a perverse child against its
mother, probably excited by a spirit of hell, their eyes
charged with remorse, corroding as well as malicious,
in a glacial silence, not daring to emit the vast ungrate-
ful meditations concealed in their hearts, so full were
they of injustice and of horror, and saddening with
pity the God of compassion ; sometimes, at every
moment of the day from the beginning of childhood
to the end of old age, spreading incredible curses with-
out commonsense against everything that breathes,
against themselves and against Providence, prostituting
women and children, and dishonouring thus the parts
of the body consecrated to modesty. Then the seas
lift up their waters and swallow the ships in their
abysses ; tempests, earthquakes, overthrow houses ;
plague, diverse diseases decimate whole families in
prayer. But men do not perceive it. I have seen them
also reddening, paling with shame for their conduct
on the earth: rarely. Tempests, sisters of the storm;
bluish firmament whose beaty I do not admit ; hypo-
critical sea, image of my heart ; earth of mysterious
bosom; inhabitants of the spheres; universal nature;
God, who created it with magnificence, I invoke you —
show me a good man! . . . But let your grace double
my natural forces since, at the sight of such a monster,
I may die of astonishment: people have died from less.
* * *
One's nails ought to be allowed to grow for fifteen
days. Oh ! how sweet it is to tear brutally from its
bed a child which has nothing on its upper lip, and,
with wide open eyes, to pretend to pass one's hand
over his forehead brushing the beautiful hair back-
wards! Then, suddenly, at the moment he least
expects it, to plunge long nails into his soft bosom,
in such a way that he does not die ; for, if he were to
die one would not have later the sight of his miseries.
Afterwards, one drinks the blood by licking the
wounds; and during this time, which should last as
long as eternity lasts, the child weeps. Nothing is so
good as his blood extracted as I have just said, and
still warm, unless it be his tears, bitter as salt. Man,
have you never tasted your blood when you cut your
finger by accident? How good it is; for it is tasteless.
Besides, do you not remember one day in the midst
of lugubrious reflections to have carried your hand —
hollowed at the base — to your sick countenance wet with
that which fell from your eyes ; which hand afterwards
moved fatalistically towards your mouth, which drew
up the tears in long draughts from their cup, trembling
like the teeth of the pupil who looks sideways at him
who was born to be his oppressor. How good these
tears are, for they have the taste of vinegar. They
are like the tears of her who loves most ; but the tears
of a child are better to the palate. He does not betray,
not yet knowing evil: she who loves most betrays
sooner or later. ... I discover this by analogy,
although I know nothing of friendship and love (it is
probable that I shall never accept them, at least from
the human race). Then since your blood and your
tears do not disgust you, feed yourself, feed yourself
with confidence on the tears and on the blood of the
adolescent. Bind his eyes while you tear his palpita-
ting flesh ; and, after hearing for long hours his
sublime cries, like the piercing rattles which in a fight
issue from the gullets of the agonised wounded, then,
having dashed away like an avalanche, you will rush
in from the next room and you will pretend to arrive
in his aid. You will untie his hands with their swollen
nerves and veins, you will restore sight to his terrified
eyes while you recommence drinking his tears and
blood. How true repentance is ! The divine spark
which is in us, which appears so seldom, now shows
itself: too late! How the heart overflows in trying to
console the innocent whom one has injured: "Adoles-
cent, you who have just suffered cruel pains, who could
have committed on you a crime which I cannot name !
Unhappy one that you are ! How you suffer ! And
if your mother knew this she could not be nearer to
death, so feared by the guilty, than I am now. Alas !
what is good and what is evil ! Is it the same thing
by which Ave witness our impotence with rage, and the
passion to attain to the infinite even by the maddest
ways? Or are they two different things? Yes . . ■.
may they be rather the same thing . . . for, if they
are not, what shall I become on the day of judgment !
Adolescent, forgive me ; he who is before your noble
sacred face — it is he who has broken your bones and
torn the flesh which hangs from different parts of your
body. Is it a delirium of my sick reason, is it a secret
instinct which does not depend on my reasonings, like
that of an eagle rending its prey, which has urged me
to commit this crime; and yet I suffer as much as my
victim ! Adolescent, forgive me. Once emerged from
this transitory life I desire that we should be interlaced
for all eternity ; to form one single being, my mouth
against yours. Even in this manner my punishment
will not be complete. Then you will tear me, un-
ceasingly, with teeth and nails together. I will deck
my body with scented garlands for this holocaust of
expiation, and we will both suffer ; I, at being torn,
you, at tearing me . . . my mouth against your mouth.
adolescent, with fair hair, with eyes so gentle, will
you now do what I counsel you? In spite of yourself
1 desire that you do it and render my conscience
happy." After speaking thus you will have done evil
to a human being and at the same time you will be
loved by this being; it is the greatest happiness con-
ceivable. Later you will be able to put him in a hos-
pital; for, being impotent, he will be unable to earn
his living. You will be called good, and laurel crowns
and gold medals will hide your naked feet, spread on
the great tomb, with a face of age. You, whose
372
THE EGOIST
October 1. KM
2
W
S
Eh
bo
<
<
o
z
?
o
s
m
C
O
a
as
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
373
name I will not write on this page which consecrates
the holiness of crime, I know that your forgiveness was
immense as the universe. But I still exist.
*• * *
I have made a pact with prostitution so as lo sow
discord among families. I remember the night which
preceded this dangerous liaison. I saw before me a
tomb. I heard a shining glow-worm, as large as a
house, say to me: "I will enlighten you. Read the
inscription. This supreme order does not come from
me." A vast blood-coloured light, at the sight of which
my teeth chattered and my arms fell inert, .spread
through the atmosphere to the horizon. I leant against
a ruined wall, for I was almost falling, and read :
" Here lies a youth who died of consumption: you know
why. Do not pray for him." Many men would not
perhaps have had so much courage as I. During this
time a beautiful naked woman came and lay at my feet.
With a sad face 1 said to her "Arise." I held out to
her the hand with which the fratricide strangles his
sister. The glow-worm to me: "Take a stone and slay
her." "Why?" said I. And he to me: 'Take care
of yourself; the feeblest, because I am the strongest.
She is called Prostitution." Tears in my eyes, rage in
my heart, I felt an unknown force bom in me. I
picked up a huge rock; after many efforts I raised it
with difficulty to the height of my chest ; I placed it
on my shoulders with my arms. I climbed to the
summit of a mountain : from this 1 crushed the glow-
worm. Its head was thrust a man's height, into the
earth ; the stone rebounded to the height of six
churches. It fell back into a lake whose waters sank
for an instant, whirling round, scooping out an im-
mense reversed cone. Calm reappeared on the sur-
face ; the blood-coloured light glimmered no more.
"Alas!" cried the beautiful woman, ''What have you
done!" I to her: "I prefer you to him, because I
pity the unfortunate. It is not your fault if eternal
justice has created you." She to me: "One day men
will do me justice ; 1 will tell you no more. Let me
go to hide my infinite sadness in the depths of the
sea. You and the hideous monsters which swarm in these
black abysses alone do not despise me. You are good.
Farewell, you who have loved me!" I to her: ''Fare-
well ! Once more ; farewell ! I shall always love you !
From to-day 1 abandon virtue." That is why, people,
when you hear the winter wind moan on the sea and
near its shores, or over the great cities which for long
have put on mourning for me, or across the icy polar
regions, you shall say: "That is not the spirit of Cod
passing: it is the bitter sigh of prostitution joined with
the heavy groans of the Montevidean." Children, T
tell you this. Then, full of compassion, kneel down ;
and let men, more numerous than lice, make long
prayers.
* # *
In the moonlight near the sea in the isolated parts
of the country one sees — plunged in bitter reflections
everything decked in yellow, indecisive, fantastic
shapes. The shadow of the trees runs, goes, returns
sometimes quickly, sometimes slowly in diverse forms,
flattening itself, pressing itself against the ground.
Formerly, when I was carried on the wings of youth,
this made me wonder, seemed strange to me ; now I am
used to it. The wind moans its languorous notes across
the leaves, the owl sings its sad complaint which makes
the hair rise on those who hear it. Then the dogs
become furious and break their chains, escape from
distant farms; they rush hither and thither across the
country, a prey to madness. Suddenly they stop, their
eyes on fire, glancing on every side with ferocious
timidity; and, as elephants before death cast across
the desert one last glance at the sky, lifting their
trunks in despair, dropping their ears inert, so the dogs
drop their ears inert, lift their heads, swell their terri-
ble throats and begin to howl in turn, like a cat
wounded in the belly on a roof, like a woman in labour,
like a man dying of plague in a hospital, like a girl
singing some sublime air, against the stars of the north,
against the stars of the east, against the stars of the
south, against the stars of the we6l : against the moon;
against the mountains lying far off like giant rocks in
the darkness; against the cold air which they breathe
with full lungs and which makes the ulterior of their
nostrils red, burning ; against the silence of the night ;
against, the screech-owls whose oblique flight brushes
their muzzles bearing a rat or a frog in their beaks,
living food, sweet to their young; again.-.! the hares
which disappear in the winking of an eye : against the
thief who flies on his galloping horse after committing
a crime; against the snakes stirring the heath, which
makes their skin tremble and their teeth gnash ;
against their own howls which terrify them ; against
the. toads which they bite with a sharp snap of their
jaws (why did they leave the marsh?); against the
trees whose leaves, gently rocked, are so many mys-
teries which they do not understand and which they
try to fathom with fixed intelligent eyes; against the
spiders, suspended between their long legs, which
grasp the trees to save themselves ; against the ravens
which have found no food all day long and return on
tired wings to their perch ; against, the rocks of the
shore ; against the fire which appears on the masts of
invisible ships; against, the dull sound of the waves;
against the great fish which show their black fins as
they swim and then plunge into the abyss; and against
man who enslaves them. After which they once more
dash across the country, leaping, with bleeding paws,
over ditches, roads, fields, grasses and steep rocks.
They are as if seized with madness, seeking a vast
mere to quench their thirst. Their prolonged howls
terrify nature itself. Woe to the belated traveller!
These friends of the graveyard will hurl themselves
upon him, tear him, devour him, with their mouths
which run with blood, for they have not spoiled their
teeth. The wild animals, not daring to approach to
share the meal of flesh, slink trembling out of sight.
After some hours the dogs, harassed by running hither
and thither, almost dead, their tongues hanging out of
their mouths, fall upon each other without knowing
what they are doing and tear each other into a thousand
shreds with incredible speed. They do not act thus
from cruelty. One day, my mother, with glassy eyes,
said to me: "When you are in bed and hear the howl-
ing of the dogs in the country, hide under your sheet,
do not turn to derision what they do: they have the
insatiable thirst for the infinite, like you, like me, like
the rest of human beings with long pale faces. I even
permit you to stand at the window aud to watch this
spectacle, which is sublime." Since that day I respect
the wishes of the dead. Like the dogs I feel the neces-
sity for the infinite. ... I cannot, I cannot satisfy that
need ! I am the son of man and of woman according
to what they tell me. That astounds me. ... I
thought I was something very different ! After all,
what does my origin matter? If it. had depended upon
my own will I would rather be the son of a female
shark, whose hunger is the companion of tempests, and
of the tiger of recognised cruelty : I should not be so
evil. You, who look at me, depart, for my breath ex-
hales poison. None has yet observed the green lines
on my forehead ; nor the starting bones of my meagre
face which are like the hones of a great fish or like the
rocks which cover the sea-shore, or like abrupt alpine
hills over which I often wandered when I had hair of a
different colour. And, when 1 ramble about the habi-
tations of man during stormy nights, with ardent eyes,
my hair beaten with the wind of tempests, isolated like
a stone in the middle of a road, I cover my withered
face with a piece of velvet black as the soot in the
inside of chimneys: eyes must not be a witness of the
ugliness which the Supreme Being has laid upon me
with a smile of powerful hate. Every morning, when
the sun rises for others, spreading salutary joy and
warmth through all nature while not one of my features
moves, watching fixedly shadow-filled space, crouched
in the end of my beloved cave, in a despair which in-
toxicates like wine, I tear into ribbons with puissant
fingers the flesh of my breast. Yet I know that T was
not mad ! Yet I know that I am not the only sufferer '.
Like a condemned man who tests his muscles while
374
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
reflecting on their fate and knowing that he will soon
die on a scaffold, so, standing on my straw bed with
closed eyes I slowly turn my neck from right to left,
from left to right, for whole hours at a time ; I do not
fall in a dead faint. From time to time when my neck
cannot turn any further in one direction, and stops so
as to turn in the opposite direction, I suddenly look
at the horizon across the rare crevices left in the thick
branches which cover the entrance: I see nothing!
Nothing . . . unless it be the country dancing in whirl-
winds with the trees and with long files of birds cros-
sing the air. This troubles my blood and brain. . . .
Who hits me on the head with a bar of iron like a
hammer beating on an anvil ?
('/'« he continued.)
Translator's Note. — This amazing work, of which we print
here the first instalment, is, in some ways, one of the most
marvellous achievement' in modern literature. The author was
a Frenchman from Montevideo. His name was Isidore Dueaase
but he assumed the nam de plume of Camte tie Lautreamont.
The hook was written when the author was seventeen years old
in 1867. Dncasse died of fever at the age of twenty. Had lie
lived, lie might have been " cue of the glories of French litera-
ture." As it is the work remaining is extremely unequal.
Lautreamont was not mad, in spite of all opinions to the
contrary. This has been proved by M. L. Geuonceatix, in his
preface to the •■Chants de Maldoror." Neither did he suffer
from any form of sexual aberration. He was simply an auda-
cious Renins who dared to think what no one had thought before
and who dressed his thought- in such supreme irony that he
really appears mad to the bourgeois intelligence of the modern
world.
SOME ITALIAN SONNETS.
(TRECENTO.)
THE GARLAND OF MONTHS.
By FoLGOBE da Sax Gemioniano.
July.
For July in Siena of the paven ways I give you
narrow -waisted flagons of sweet white wine, and in your
cellars iced vajano wines, and morning and evening you
shall eat in company
Of huge jellies, roasted partridges, young pheasants,
boiled capons, sovereign kids, and- for those that like
it — veal with garlic sauce.
And let the good time and good life pass by, and go
not outside for fear of the. great heat, but wear within
doors thin silk garments of fair fashioning;
When you carouse, do so quietly, and always keep
your tables replenished and long for no wife to spoil
everything.
August,
For August 1 give you thirty castles in a valley oT the
mountainous Alps where no sea-wind blows, and where
you shall be healthy and clear as a star ;
Ami palfreys for you to mount and ride at evening and
morning. Let each of your lauds be near the others so
that a mile's riding be your whole day's work
Turning the whole time homewards. Through the
valley shall How a stream running gently day and night ;
And you shall stay in the shade all the noontide; and
keep your purses always open-mouthed for the best
cheer in Tuscany.
September.
For September I give you many delights: falcons,
goshawks, merlins and hawks, bird-leashes, short lances,
jesses and shooting-bags, little dogs with bells, good
meat and gauntlets.
Darts, straight long-carrying cross-bows, long-bows,
arrows, bullets and bullet-cases, moulting gerfalcons and
goshawks taken from the nest, and all other soaring
birds
Which are good for attacking and seizing ; and all the
time you shall give to one another and steal (1) without
quarrelling
And when you meet with other folk your purse shall be
ready to spend and all of you shall send avarice into
exile.
October.
For October I beg you, my sons, to go to a fair house
in the country and take your ease and go a-fowling on
foot or horse back as it pleases you ;
Tn the evening you shall dance in the ball-room and
drink sweet new wine and get tipsy ; there is no better
life than this in truth, and this is as true as that a florin
is yellow.
And after you get up in the morning, wash your face
and hands ; roast beef and wine are good medicine
By the mass ! and so you shall be healthier than fish
in a lake, or river-fish, or sea-fish, living moreover the
better life of Christians.
November.
And for November you shall go to the baths of
Petriuolo with thirty mules laden with money ; let the
street be covered with silk, silver cups and pewter
bottles,
And let all the shopkeepers make their profit out of
you. Your torches and candlesticks shall come from
Chiareta, and from Gaeta your lemon-flavoured sweet-
meats ; and let each one drink and rejoice the company.
The cold shall be great and your fires frequent;
pheasants, partridges, pigeons, ragouts, hares, roe-
bucks, roast and boiled —
Let your appetites be always ready for them ; at flight
there shall be wind and pouring rain but you will be well
tucked up in bed.
December.
And for December I give you a city in the plain,
ground-floor rooms and huge fires, woven carpets, chess
hoards and games, and lighted torches ; and do you have
always gifts in your hand;
And I give you for host a wine-bibber and a gourmet;
and dead pigs and most skilful cooks, neat morsels, each
one good and sumptuous (?) and wine-butts hugcr than
San Galgano.
And you shall be well-clothed and wrapped in long
gowns, mantles and cloaks, and in fine voluminous hoods ;
And make scorn of sad vagabonds, of miserable mourn-
ful wretches ; misers — have nought to do with them 1
The Conclusion.
.My sonnet, to Nicholo di Nisi, lie who is full of gentle-
ness, say on my part with much gladness that I am
ready to do him any service.
And that his friendship and company are dearer to me
than the worth of all Paris, and that if only he had the
Emperor's riches he would stand with me better than
Francis at Assisi.
Commend me to him many times and to his company
and to Anchaiono, without, whom the joyful band could
not be.
''Your Folgore da San Gemigniano," say, "sends
this." And make this embassy; that you come thither
with his heart in your hand.
John Feltox.
THE PROSE OF FREDERIC
MANNING.
By Richaed Aldington.
SOME time ago an article on the prose of AY. H.
Hudson was published in these columns. That
article was written mostly because I admired
Mr. Hudson's prose, but it was also written to defend
a critical attitude very dear to a certain slightly elderly
friend of mine. Unfortunately, or perhaps fortunately,
my article did not please this gentlemen, who remarked
that it was "the most insulting thing he'd ever read,"
or words to that effect. Now, if that very humble
appreciation of Mr. Hudson was too luke-warm for this
partisan of his, I know that an appreciation of Mr.
Manning will drive my friend into an ecstasy of contempt
for me, for Mr. Manning, for everything we ever wrote
or said or admired.
All this, of course, has nothing to do with the reader
of this article, but it has something to do with the
October 1, 1914
THE EGOIST
375
:
critical attitude. For, apart from mere reviewing —
which covers nearly all our ''criticism" and is indeed
merely a subsidiary publisher's puff— there are now two
fcritieal attitudes. One is the '"sound" attitude; it
believes what the Universities believe ; if it ventures to
praise any author not approved by the Universities it
does so for two reasons. First, because this person is
probably the sort of person the Universities will approve,
and secondly, from motives of personal friendship.
Sir K. L.'s book must be praised because he is a Balliol
man, because the book is "sound" — i.e., stodgy — and
because he is a friend of the critic. The other critical
attitude is perhaps a little more stimulating and
amusing. It condemns ferociously all works of what-
ever eminence, genius or beauty whatsoever, if they
deviate from its strict and original rules ; it abuses the
critic's enemies, all the enemies of his family unto the
third and fourth generation ; en revanche, it praises all
the critic's friends, all the friends of his family, of his
wife and of his wife's friends. Thus, if \vc suppose that
one of the critic's rules is that the word " cow " shall
never be used on the same page, as the word "cough,"
and that an author should violate this rule, it then
follows that such a book is bad no matter what its merit
may be. Or if a book be written by a friend of some
enemy of (he critic the critic's enemy having attained
a more lucrative and honourable position in the literary
world — then again the book is bad. But if, on the other
hand, the, friend of some titled lady who is a friend of
the critic's mother-in-law should write a book, then,
ipso Facto, the book is good.
The miserable book-lover, having suffered from the
members of both these schools, emerges, as it were, from
a violent strain, pale, wan, and with thin locks. He says
to himself, "All these things are wrong; also, they are
all rot." He says, "Any book of which one single para-
graph makes me think or makes me feel is a good book."
Rut, alas, he soon finds that every book can make him
feel or think something, if it be only to think t lie author
of the. book an unspeakable ass and to feel a potent,
yearning to kick him.
"Somewhere, somewhere," he cries, "there must be
a real critical attitude, which is no respecter of persons,
which is appreciative of merit in any and every form,
and which is not blinded by charlatanism and personal
feeling ! "
Is there such a thing 1 I like to think that Mr. Manning
possesses it.
We have gone rather far before coming to Mr.
Manning, but this question of criticism is of the very
essence of our literature. It needs constant discussion.
A man of parts who could really work out an original,
sincere criticism could determine the literary taste of
the next twenty years. Ruskin did it in his time ; Pater
in his. To-day we either copy these two or weakly and
petulantly react against their ideas. As far as I can
see we have three men to-day who might, without
arrogance, pretend to the title of critic. These are
Ford Madox Hueffer, Sturge Moore and Frederic
Manning. Each of these gentlemen has curious limita-
tions and none of them have the influence we should
wish for them. Wisdom is still received coldly while
folly stalks well-paid through the pages of the Press.
Mr. Manning is the youngest of these three ; if he is the
least original in manner, he is not the least fertile in
ideas. And he has fascination. It is true, he has kept
something of the University attitude ; the pale shade of
Pater dims some of his best pages, and not all the
delicate irony, which he has inherited from modern
France, can purge his pages of perilous Paterisms.
But — and this is a large but. — the fact that Mr. Manning
has been bold enough to adopt and even embellish the
Epicurean attitude is remarkable at a time when such an
attitude is in great discredit with all young men of parts.
It is absurd and ignorant to say that Mr. Manning is a
repetition of the "nineties"; he has simply read the
books of more languages and centuries, looked at more
pictures, heard better music and thought more imagina-
tively than most of his contemporaries.
"Ataraxia, a withdrawing, a folding of the hands," a
standing-aside from the great noisy concourse of the
world— that is the key-note of Epicureanism. We live in
a world of vain phantasmagoria with which men are
ceaselessly and uselessly troubled before they learn
wisdom. Men are moved by gross or trivial passions,
by blind affections, by pitiful devotion to vain, sounding
abstractions— glory, honour, affection— and the tears
and the gladness of this mean multitude are nothing,
the race of man is but a few dancing motes, a pinch of
colured dust between the fingers of death. But beyond
the world, beyond the great rivers of the ocean of space,
sit the high gods calm in the cool golden air; there is
no snow nor wind nor rain in that place ; and the sighs
and prayers of men fall at the feet of the gods but cannot
trouble their ineffable happiness. That is what the
Epicurean believes, and he believes that happiness
exists in becoming as like the gods as is consistent with
the poverty of human strength. "To contemplate with
appropriate emotions the spectacle of life " — that, or
something like it, is the Epicurean attitude.
If, by chance, that were read to Mr. Manning, he would
probably say that it was nonsense, that it was not
Epicureanism at all, least of all his Epicureanism. A
chacun sa philosophie is the motto to-day, for "all that
we know is that we know nothing "—and even that is
not certain.
Still, Mr. Manning's "Scenes and Portraits" are, we
may take it, a scries of studies in chronological order
putting forth the critical attitude of the modern Epi-
curean towards life and literature. Towards literature
largely, for though Mr. Manning discusses contemporary
theories with great insight, he does so a little languidly
and seems to be much happier when he is speaking of
the people of books, like all Epicureans who seem to
derive the vicarious happiness promised by their philo-
sophy through the contemplation of literature rather
than through the contemplation of life. It is this fact
which explains the extraordinary hatred of Epicureanism
among the middle classes and among the writers of
literary reviews.
As a literary critic Mr. Manning is fascinating. There
is not the faintest suspicion of charlatanism — with which
so many of our writers are tainted — in any of his essays.
He is always perfectly sincere, his views are mostly in
accord with his main philosophy — 1 mean that he has no
incoherences, no blatant contradictions, signs of funda-
mental insincerity — and he is often as original as a man
can be in a world where nothing is new. At least one
of his critical remarks, namely, where he says that the
little genre pictures at the beginning of the cantos of
the Divine Comedy are like large illuminated letters,
has become classic among a small circle of his admirers.
Indeed, his whole criticism of Dante is admirable. In
a dialogue between Machiavelli and Thomas Cromwell —
more in the manner of Pater than of Landor or Lucian —
he criticises the political, religious and poetical aspects
of Dante's poetry, and has some new appreciation, some
new view-point for each of them. His decors are exact,
and therefore beautiful. The villa at San Casciano is
delicately described, unintentionally, as it were, by hints
and casual remarks. The minds of Machiavelli and of
Cromwell are indicated as much by their unconscious
movements, by their clothes, by their jewellery even, as
by their spoken words. And Mr. Manning, in each of
his " scenes" has reproduced the manner of his period —
a virtue our historical novelists cannot claim. For
instance, the letter written by Cromwell to his friend
is, barring the spelling, so nearly like a piece of prose of
the reign of Henry VIII. that it might have been written
by the Blessed Sir Thomas More himself.
Mr. Manning must be content to hear himself called
an Epicurean, but the difference between his Epi-
cureanism and that of Pater is that the latter seems
always perfectly self-satisfied while Mr. Manning
appears to suffer from a perpetual dissatisfaction. He
seems to be struggling always towards something else,
towards something more satisfying than Lucretius, but
it looks as if he were damned by irony, the mark, the
pleasure, and the curse of distinguished minds.
Merodach, King of Ur, standing on his marble terrace,
smelled the scent of flowers and heard the song of
nightingales ; and he grew sad thinking that he would
die, and be forgotten, that his name and his palace and
his people would be blotted out. When he does the
376
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
Epicurean thing, when he seeks ataraxia in the company
01 his wives, Mr. Manning cruelly conies to him in the
person ot Bagoas, the high priest, and macerates the
soul of the unhappy Merodach with mellifluous ironies
on the fragility of human happiness and the futility of
human effort.
Indeed, with all its charm and beauty, Mr. Manning's
book reads like a commentary on the most famous quota-
tion from Ecclesiastes. Merodach, Protagoras, Serenus
—the friend of Paul— Cromwell, Machiavelli. Francis of
Assisi, Innocent III., Renan, and Leo XIII.— through
what Gourmont-like irony is it that Mr. Manning makes
all these great men and their works seem vain and
Foolish? Perhaps it is not Ecclesiastes, perhaps he has
only— like France, like Gourmuut, like so many brilliant
men of to-day — brooded something too deeply over the
words of the " Master," as Mr. Manning calls him, over
the tremendous lines of Lucretius. A book remains to
be written on the influence of Lucretius on our time. In
Mr. Manning's case the influence is shared by Plato
among the. ancients and Renan and France among the
moderns. Perhaps The House of Euripides contains too
many reminiscences of the divine dialogues, perhaps
The Friend of Paul reminds one a little too much of the
early part of Bur la Pierre Blanche, but one easily passes
these trifles over in admiration for the general structure
of Mr. Manning's book and for the many brilliant
thoughts it. contains.
Dissatisfaction mingled with an exquisite appreciation
of beauty, the irony of Fiance wedded to the {esthetic
perceptions of Pater— that is the, book's character.
Few people have loved more than Mr. Manning the
poetry, the charm, the beauty of the life of Francesco
Bernadone. But at the same time none of his lovers has
so clearly realised the essential defects of the Franciscan
movement. The .1 esters of the Lord reads like an
extract from the Fioretti. accompanied by a slightly
ironical criticism. 1 do not recall anything T have read
which was at once more beautiful, more pathetic- and
more ironical than the end of this exquisite essay.
Francis and his followers returning gladly from Rome
with permission to found the new order fall fainting by
the roadside in the heat of the sun. A young man going
by in a cart finds them and revives them with wine.
When they got to Orte that night, Francis suddenly
said, 'That was an angel who succored us." And they
marvelled that they had not known it sooner. " They
were twelve fools.'' said the young man to his sweet-
heart.
I called this "The prose of Frederic Manning," and I
have not said a word about his prose ! It is, at least to
certain tastes, a little too ornate, too finely chased, too
precious. That is the inevitable result of the Epicurean
attitude. But it is most certainly never cheap prose,
and if we do not always hear Mr. Manning's own voice
in his writing, if he gives us something which is less
austere and restrained than the speech of "one gentle-
man talking to another" he has at least an academic
grace of expression finer than any living Englishman
and a felicity of epithet as mellifluous as that of Paler
if not as precise as that of Anatole France.
ART AND DRAMA.
THE WAR AND SOME SURVIVALS.
-\17"AR has awakened the gregarious thrill. Patriotic
VV devotion is about. The word soldier has not
only originated a queer species of attachment
between persons who are capable of murdering each
other, but has become synonymous with every noble
virtue. OF course all this glorification of the fifteen-
penny hired cut-throat is the merest drivel of the drivell-
ing*. If soldiering in the beginning meant the strong
gaining a natural advantage over the weak, it means so
no longer. If war once had a biological cause and
just ifica' ion it has none to-day. In the old days every
male member of a tribe went to war. Each went in
obedience to primal instincts. Each knew that he must
slay or be slain, that, his own tribe would perish if it did
not go out and exterminate an enemy tribe. That was
the rule of the war game as it was played by physical
natural selection. To-day the causes and justifications
of war are not the same. If we analyse them we
certainly cannot say they are biological. War as we
know it is a form of political sport, and soldiers are
creatures chosen for their fitness to take part in it.
They are simply hirelings. Many I daresay have not
an ounce of fight in them. They are bought to shoot or
stab, and they go forth to shoot or stab, leaving the
charlatans and weaklings behind them. This is the
rule of the game as it is played by unnatural selection.
* * *
Modern war is the sport of kings, capitalists, political
welshers, blacklegs, thieves, country snatchers,
tricksters and journalistic loafers. It is approved by
persons of mean intelligence. It is a dubious game, one
to shudder at. Its chief aim is to make an end of the
strong species. The German Emperor entered the
present war with no illusion as to its killing off capacity.
He foresaw that nine-tenths of his strongest Germans
might "go down." But he was not so clear on other
points. He declared that Germans were going to
carry cultural enlightenment to the cuds of the earth.
But he did not say how they were going to do so with
nine-tenths of their throats cut. Nor is the Kaiser's
prophet, General von Bernhardi, more explicit. He-
states in his pamphlet on " Germany and the Next
War," his conception of the biological cause and justi-
fication of the war and leaves it there. War, according
to Bernhardi, is a natural law of the physical world; it
is played both by the organic and inorganic. There is
war in the air above us, in the earth beneath us, and in
the waters under the earth. And I suppose there always
will be war as long as micro-organisms, vegetables,
animals and men have arms to fight with and long legs
to bolt with. Apparently upon such physical facts
Bernhardi builds up his wild doctrine of the inevitable-
ness of war and its necessity to the advance of the
German Empire. War, he seems to say, has produced
the German super-professor. And he might have added,
war will exterminate the said professor — if it lasts long
enough. According to the Kaiser's intention, if the war
began with the "flower of his flock," it will end with
the " cats and dogs." .
* * *
Of course, Bernhardi is concerned with Hie physical
basis of life, and has no apprehension of the meta-
physical and mystic bases. Perhaps it is not unreason-
able to say that war is inevitable upon physical con-
ditions of existence, just as peace is inevitable upon
spiritual or mystic conditions. The one presupposes
material accretion with its enormous sacrifices of
individual powers and joys; the other, spiritual
simplification with its enormous gain of individual
control of the great forces of life. The one breeds
gregariousness. the willingness to serve others and the
accompanying curse of mechanical drudgery, com-
pulsion, service, and dirty work of all kinds for one's
neighbour. The other fosters self-herviee, the power
over self for self alone and not for the purpose of
exploiting weaker selves. It may be that social service
is at the root of modern war. and war will not cease till
social service has been abolished.
* * *
War and conflict, then, have not a mystic basis simply
because on the mystic basis conflict yields to unfolding.
A mystic, in fact, is one who enters the kingdom of
reality with the avowed object of attaining a reasonable
self-interest in that kingdom. Nowadays he has no
illusion about renunciation, and does not seek to become
merged or lost in something or other. On the contrary,
he hopes to find and assert his individualised soul, and
to attain its highest strength and power by the simple
process of unfolding in harmony with its spiritual
environment. And it is conceivable that as he gradually
finds and developes his Self in spirit, so all material
objects become not only unserviceable but invisible to
him. As he ascends he sees the light. And straight-
way all the things he knows, the burden of his five great
physical needs, all that material civilisation has com-
October 1, 1914
THE EGO I ST
377
plicated, piled and fastened upon him, falls to the
ground. He wants these things no longer. His soul
will transmute Soul into sustenance. And as soon as
Soul rules the body it will transmute that into its own.
So he turns from physical to soul-subsistence. The
natural effect of this development and the absence of
disturbing forces, is the growth of inward peace and the
consciousness that only through peace can man attain
the highest strength and power. The inference from
all this is that men must first be at peace with their own
selves before they can be at peace with each other's
self.
# * *
So it comes to this, that War or Conflict is the sign of
man's physical consciousness; peace or unfolding, of his
mystic consciousness. This distinction may be applied
to plays. And if, as I believe, drama exists funda-
mentally in the motions of a fluid universe, and has,
therefore, a mystic basis, only those plays which unfold
in harmony with these motions, may be said to be truly
dramatic. Hut I need not examine the point now. I
hope to return continually to this subject of the mystic
basis of Drama. The definition of Drama and the
drama as un-warlike, affords a clue to the position of
I he English theatre and form of play both at the begin-
ning and the end of the war. Roughly speaking, when
war broke out both the English theatre and play had
become thoroughly Germanised. I had just published
a book on this aspect, of which the " Saturday Review "
said: "The book is a long blast in favour of looking at
the theatre in a true prospective. London is nowhere
and nothing so far as the European art of theatre is
concerned. It gets every vital idea after every other
European capital has discarded it- . - . We cannot
dance or sing or produce plays or light a stage without
celebrating as a novelty something which has already
been exhausted in Moscow or Berlin." Indeed, as the
book shows, English producers have been busy for
some time filching German ideas, notably those concern-
ing the Repertory Theatre, ensemble acting, National
Theatre and the application of the new principles of art
to the theatre. Likewise the English playwright has
borrowed the German dialectical form of play. Mr.
Bernard Shaw seized on the Form as the most suitable
for agitating the country with Fabian schemes. In-
tellectually speaking, "the druma " at the beginning of
the war was thoroughly militarised.
* * *
What effect will the war have upon our study of
German ideals? If, as some prophets maintain, the
present war is going to kill the desire for war, it may
put an end to the love of conflict in the theatre. A
desire for peace might awaken a desire for plays with a
mystic tendency. This would mean the encouragement
of one German ideal at least. For it was Germany in
the person of Wagner who made the modern discovery
of the mystic Form of drama, and bequeathed it to Craig.
Reinhardt, and others. Wagner, in fact, introduced a
fluid universe to the modern theatre, Ultimately, I
hope, this universe will replace the grossly material
world which now disgraces the theatre. In any case the
seed is there. The German ideal has already initiated
a search for intimacy, this being the first essential step
in the wider search for the eternal principles and
qualities of the Cniversal Spirit in the theatre. The
war, as we know, has suspended the search, and for the
moment Reinhardtism has disappeared from the London
stage. All that remains iR the rank odour of un-
intelligent imitation from " Kismet," and two recruiting
plays that fonn an up-to-date variety of Parker's Potted
Pageant. I will deal with the foolishness of (he latter
another time. The shrill stupidity of "Kismet" need
not live so long.
» * #
"Kismet" exemplifies the commercial conception of
play production. It has nothing to do with art. Let
me illustrate my meaning by the respective conceptions
of producing one act. The act in question is described
as 'The Courtyard of a Poor House." The commercial
actor-manager's ideal is to produce a workmanlike act
governed by the commercial laws of stagecraft. His
great business in producing is to please the public and
get knighted. In other words, to make a show of him-
self. So he is guided by two principles. The first
principle is that the interest should be concentrated on
him by every hackneyed mechanical device. The second
principle is that the interest should be concentrated on
him by the subordinate mimes. The principles are
applied to the speech and acting, and not to the
decorated screen projected by the act in order to conceal
the bare walls of the stage and to heighten its own
illusion. Obviously he does not understand the signifi-
cance of the screen, nor its acting value, and is there-
fore unable to make it act. The result is an enormous
waste of money and material. Hugh sums are spent on
the "real thing" when an inartistic substitute would
do. Interest is centred and frittered away on iin-
significant objects. And no intelligent use is made of
decorations. They are false in key, have no relation to
each other, and are obscured. For instance in " Kismet "
a black figure is kept continually moving in deep black
shadow. Thus, in the act under consideration, the
screen (supplied to order by scene painter Harker),
becomes an actor-manager's crude device for self-
aggrandisement.
The ideal of the artist is different. He seeks to pro-
duce an act, having balance and harmony in all its
parts and in which everything is subordinated to attain
a single effect. His first business is to determine the
screen demanded by the act. His second, to keep the
lines and colours moving, composing and recomposing,
to suggest the unfolding of the dominant and subordinate
motives. In the act in question he is given a love
motive which he is asked to unfold by means of three
or four characters and his stock in trade of symbolic
line and colour. Let us suppose that he sees this love
motive creating the self-protective illusion of a court-
yard whose walls are neutral in tone and Arabian in
architecture. Across this background he draws a veil
of grey and deep blue shadows. In thus starting with
a cold register of neutralised reds, yellows, and greens,
he would not only suggest the unhappy mood of the
woman awaiting her lover, but allow himself scope for
lifting the veil by raising the colours as the act pro-
ceeds. In order to show the process of lifting the veil
let me briefly describe one or two details of the produc-
tion. The first scene of the act is simply a preparation
scene. The love woman is expecting her lover, and the
author has provided her with an attendant old woman
for the purpose of preparing for his entrance. Both are
seated centre. In Mr. Oscar Asche's production the
love woman wears a meaningless costume and is seated
before a loom with two balls of unimportant coloured
wool. In the reconstructed scene she is dressed in grey
blue and seated against the blue black doorway up
centre. In front of her is a green loom with four balls
of coloured wool, green, violet, yellow, and red. Above
the doorway is a balconied window draped with touches
of bright colour expressing joy and passion, and an-
nouncing the coming of the lover. Everything being
ready for his entrance the old woman exits. As she
does so the veil begins to lift and the colours brighten.
The grey blue love woman crosses l. and places the
green loom against the deep violet door. She returns
centre and scatters the balls of coloured avooI with rapid
movements of expectant joy. (At the Globe Theatre no
use was made of the wools or the colours. They were
packed in odd corners and left there.) The light through
the arched opening a. begins to intensify and floods the
woman and the k. half of the scene with a rich joyous
yellow, while a red lime thrown on the l. half of the
scene intensifies the reds and gives a purple tint to the
shadows. The latter half of the scene is kept in shadow
to indicate the coming of the woman's father and the
shadow thrown by him upon the love interest. The
blacks are now violet, the grey reds, crimson and the
yellows, full-bodied orange. A note of red in the lamp
at the balcony window announces the approach of the
378
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
lover. At a cue from the love woman the lover enters
through the arched opening r. in the full flood of the
yellow light in which he remains bathed throughout.
He is dressed in a neutral costume and carries a cloak
with two surfaces, one neutral, the other crimson. He
uses the crimson to intensify certain love passages. For
instance, as he makes a passionate promise to return
this passage of rich crimson added to the rich orange
and intense blue purples, together with the energy of
line of the architecture, helps to key the scene up to its
highest note of intensity. Continuing in this way, then,
the artist produces the act. His great aim is to keep
his materials a part of the fluidity of the drama, and
not to pour them into a cast iron mould after the
manner of the actor-manager.
* ~* *
It will be gathered from this suggestion for recon-
structing the principal love scene in "Kismet" that
act-designing and picture-making are not the same
tiling. The studio artist has in fact many problems to
solve before he can hope to lake the stage. Not the
least of these is that dealt, with in the "Mask" for
July. If he turns to " Some Architectural Designs of
Padre Pozzo (1649-1709)" he will learn that in designing
for the stage he has to consider the problem of sight-
line. Owing to the peculiar construction of the conven-
tional theatre only one spectator, or row of spectators —
seated centre with heads raised a little above the level
of the orchestra — ever obtain a proper and Full view of
the stage. The others spectators merely get a partial
and exaggerated view. Pozzo, who was one of the first
to show the stage wings as we know them to-day, and
" the method of designing them," has left a number of
plans, some of which the " Mask" reproduces. A study
of these sectional views of the stage and auditorium
reveals how scenery is cut up and the perspective
altered, falsified, and destroyed by the night-line
operating from all parts of a grossly absurd auditorium.
I should mention that the "Mask" usually arrives so
late as to be almost too remote for review. The present
issue was two months forthcoming. Tt wore an immacu-
late golden dress and a damp collar. Can it be that
Florence was reluctant to part with its yellow offspring.
IIvntly Carter.
THE SECRET
OF DISILLUSIONMENT.
'TI1HEKK are two tragedies in life," said the late
Oscar Wilde, "one is not getting what you want,
and the other is — getting it." What the observa-
tion lacks is novelty — and of course it is as old as the
hills— it makes up in epigrammatic neatness of form—
and universality of application. We have nearly all ex-
perienced that disappointment which follows the tame
dropping into our laps of boons which we have desired
vainly so long that we have almost become accustomed
to regarding them as unattainable. But we never get
quite used to the surprise which attends this disappoint-
ment. The one thing that we supposed necessary to
our complete happiness be it wealth, Fame, love's
fulfilment, or what not — is here in our hands at last;
and, lo and behold, we are no whit happier than we
were while we lacked it ! Or only so very little happier,
and only for so very short a time! The glamour of
distance is replaced by the crude realism of propinquity ;
the mingled pain and pleasure of desire by the mingled
pleasure and pain of possession — and criticism.
Criticism ! aye. there's the rub: we had so deliberately
and determinedly ignored its possibility in connection
with the object of our desire- while it was only that.
Here, at any rate, we had felt (because wc must and
would feel so), is a something whose flawless perfec-
tion will convert into a fellow worshipper that little imp
which has taught us to mock at so many former idols.
For, this time, if is not a question of an idol but of a
divinity, that is to say, an ideal. But the little imp
of criticism is not so easily converted: his bump of
reverence is sadly to seek: he invariably declines to
become a worshipper, much less an idolater. "Wood!
wood ! " he exclaims, " mere painted wood, as usual, my
credulous friend. So much for your divinity '. What is
there ideal about painted wood?" And the worst of it
is that we almost always end by agreeing with him:
"How short-sighted we must have been. The imp is
right as usual. It is wood, after all."
Such, almost but not quite always, is the verdict of
human consciousness upon its realised ideals. That is to
say, that, almost but not quite always, they come to be
accounted worthless, or, if indispensable, to he taken
as mere matters of course. Possession has robbed them
of nine tenths of their virtue: we wonder what on earth
could have ailed us in the days when Ave craved them
so madly, valued them so highly. W r e must have been
temporarily mad.
The fact is that achievement is a test of sincerity,
and a test from which very few emerge unscathed. It
is also a test of the fastidiousness, or, more often,
of the careless caprice, with which we have chosen our
so-called "ideals." Most people have an unhappy
knack of persuading themselves that they cannot do
without, anything which happens to attract them, pro-
vided only that it is for the moment beyond their grasp.
They do not really want it; but they allow themselves
to become obsessed by the idea that it is indispensable.
That makes them happily miserable, because they feel
that they have a grievance against destiny. There is
nothing that sentimental people — and most people are
sentimental — enjoy more. No wonder, then, that such
people are disconcerted when ironic destiny gives them
what they fancy they desire. They have gained a white
elephant, and lost their pet. grievance. It is in two ways
a bad bargain. Their white elephant is inconveniently
real : it makes real demands, which they are far from
prepared to meet. Their lost grievance made none at
all. They have to readjust their lives to the possession
of their white elephant: to build a pagoda for it in
their back garden, so to speak, and to supply its abun-
dant needs. How exasperating that is to a sentimental
dreamer, I need scarcely insist.
The exceptions to the above rule of disillusionment
are the almost negligibly few individuals who are
capable of genuine desires. These are they who realise
in advance the claims which their ideal will make when
it becomes an actuality, and quietly prepare themselves
to meet them, should they ever arise. They are con-
scious from the first of the element of glamour which in
great measure accounts for the attraction of their ideal.
They make proper allowance for that element, while
at the same time utilising it as a motive power in work-
ing for their aim. No matter if it proves ephemeral;
for the present it exists and constitutes a source of
power. Such people, even if, on attainment, they are
conscious of some disillusionment, are by no means dis-
concerted, because they have, all along," anticipated its
occurrence. The predominant feeling is one of great
satisfaction in that they have obtained what they
genuinely desired. That it proves itself real by par-
ticipating in the general imperfection of reality, is far
from being a grave deduction from its value in their
eyes: is, indeed, a main factor of its abiding charm.
Having achieved one aim of existence, they go on to
strive for the next.
Charles J. Whitby.
ECSTASIES.
When you approach
I close my eyes
To listen better,
For, like the wind.
Running through
The eolian harp
Your love,
The sight of you.
Your very recollection,
Bestirs a music in me
Fulfilling the promise
Of instruments.
M. C.
October 1, l!) 1 4
THE EGOIST
379
CONTRASTS.
When you are not by my side, dearest,
You are a stranger.
You do not love me.
I do not love you.
You might be an hemisphere away
Or dead.
When you are by my side, dearest.
Nothing exists but you.
In you are sun and warmth and light
And consolation
And the very air I breathe,
I am through you.
When you depart
I tali into space
Darkness closes round me,
I sink within myself
And would fain be nothing
And sleep.
Until the hour of your return
And I am faced by the pain
Of meeting, or not meeting you.
RONDEAU.
I never even saw you
But I felt you
And heard you.
Not a word had you spoken
And I knew your desire.
I felt your caress
Before your lips touched mine.
CORRESPONDENCE.
Note to Correspondents. — While quite willing to publish letter*
under noms dp plume, we make it a condition of publication
that the name and- address of each correspondent should be
supplied to the Editor. — Ed.
intelligibly express (he motive of the average Briton in
favouring war against Germany. Miss Marsden gives
no help except some vague phrases about status and
prestige. I don't know anyone who has any status or
prestige, or wants any (1 know I don't), yet I know-
some hundreds of people quite ardent for the war, and
some who have gone to risk their lives. The fact is
that the Humanitarianism, which Miss Marsden thinks
so much weaker than Interest, is almost the strongest
Interest there is. None but a few elementary physical
needs are anything like so strong. He who can enlist it
on his side nearly always wins; that is why all sides try
to enlist it.
" Merely the collective self-interest of the non-
fighters," Miss Marsden will reply. Perhaps so; but in
that case why call it poetic babble? For most non-
fighters are possible fighters, and the collective interest
of 2,000 million people makes a force which the force-
worshipper must respect at his peril. That is why
"noble eloquence" is not a mere sentimental satis-
faction to oneself, as Miss Marsden seems to think, but
a very practical weapon ; it cements a million weak
fibres into a club which would defy the axe of the super-
man even if he existed. (Miss Marsden says no-one
speaks of the super-man now. I regret to see her so
much afraid of Public Opinion as to let it defraud her of
a convenient name. An Egoist should lead Public
Opinion, not follow it).
Humanitarian sentiment is stronger than melinite or
turpinite, for it always controls them. Has not Miss
Marsden observed the equisite humane sentiments which
the Kaiser distributes from aeroplanes in Poland, and
which rises in chorus from all the German newspapers,
and in the letters found on German soldiers? Mere
humbug, says Miss Marsden perhaps. Do people throw
away their lives for humbug?
Success justifies any cause, says Miss Marsden, and
instances Cromwell's reputation as a kingly hero. I was
brought up to think him a murderous hypocrite. I do
not think so now. but most of the people I meet do,
especially the young ones. As for Alexander, I never
heard anyone admire him yet. Napoleon would have
been a better example for Miss Marsden, only she
chooses him as an example of failure unjustifying a
cause !
M. C.
Alston, Cumberland.
Caldwell Harpur.
CONSCIENCE AND INTEREST.
To the Editor, The Egoist.
Madam,
My remarks on classification seem to have had
some effect on Miss Marsden. and she now recognises
that one person can belong to several classes, whether
the classification is by Initiative or by some other
feature. In fact, as I said before, " initiative is never
absent, and never twice alike." This is what makes
generalisations about human classes so apt to be mere
verbalisms. I will now try to show that some more of
Miss Marsden's philosophy is merely verbal.
Anarchist and Archist are not different persons, they
are the same person seen from two sides. The Archist.
by Miss Marsden's definition, is "one who seeks to
establish the law of his own interests." Now the
interest of the Anarchist is to live in a world where no
one rules or is ruled. Hence every Anarchist seeking to
win this ideal is an Archist. (By the way, I wish Miss
Marsden would make her new words from some other
source than the overworked and confusing Greek roots).
It is indeed a most ludicrous error to assume that
interests are all material— (page 342 of the last issue) —
yet the gist of page 343 is that immaterial interests are,
"poetic babble." Nobody with any strength ever really
fights to "Right the Wrong," thinks Miss Marsden,
but I seek in vain some other set of words which will
EDITORIAL.
Letters, &C, intended for the Editor should be
addressed to Oakley House, Bloomsbury Sh-eet,
London, W.C.
PUBLICATION.
All business communications relative to the publica-
tion of The Egoist should be addressed, and all
cheques, postal and money orders, ifcc, made payable
to The New Frkkwoman, Ltd., Oakley House,
Bloomsbury Street, London, W.C, and should be
crossed " Pair's Bank, Bloomsbury Branch."
Terms of Subscript ion. —Yearly, 13/- (U.S.A.,
3 dollars 25 cents); Six Months, 6/6 (U.S.A.,
1 dollar 63 cents); Three Months, 3/3 (U.S.A.,
S4 cents). Single Copies 7d., post free to any
address in the Postal Union.
ADVERTISEMENTS.
All orders, letters, «fcc, concerning advertisements
should be addressed to the Advertisement Manager,
The Egoist, Oakley House, Bloomsbury Street,
London, W.C.
380
THE EGOIST
October 1, 1914
READERS
of
THE EGOIST
are asked to become
SUBSCRIBERS
This is the most effectual way of helping the Paper.
SUBSCRIPTIONS must be sent to
The New Free woman Ltd.,
Oakley House,
Bloomsbury Street,
London, W.C.
All Cheques. Money Orders and Postal Orders should
he crossed *' Parr's Bank, Bloomsbury Branch." and
made payable to The New Freewoman Ltd.
Km- Terms of Subscription vce below.
THE EGOIST
Subscription Form
Please send me THE EGOIST for
. . from
for which I enclose
Name_
Address
TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION :-
Yearly ••- 13,'- ; U.S.A., 3 dollars 25 cents.
Six Months ... 6 6;
Three Months 3 3 :
1 dollar 63
84
Orders should be sent to Tut: New Fbbbwomah,
Ltd., Oakley House, Bloomsbury Street, London,
W.C. All Cheques, Jlouey Orders, aud Postal
Orders .should be croBsed " Pair's Bank, Bloomsbury
Branch," aud made payable to Tun New Frbe-
rYOMAM, Ltd.
Poetry
A Magazine of Verse.
Endeavours to publish the best poems
now written in English ;
Reviews and discusses new books and
verse :
Promotes in every possible way the
interests of the art.
If you believe that this art, like paint-
ing, sculpture, music, and architecture
requires and deserves public recognition and
support, subscribe.
POETRY,
543, Cass Street, Chicago, U.S.A.
Send Poetry for one year ($1.50 enclosed)
beginning — . to
Name
Address
The Drama
736, MARQUETTE BUILDING, CHICAGO.
A Quarterly devoted to the Development of a
Wide and Intelligent Interest in Drama.
Each issue of THE DRAMA contains
a translation of a complete play.
These plays, not otherwise accessible in
English, represent especially the leading
dramatists of the continent.
THE DRAMA, in addition, devotes
attention to modern stagecraft, new types
of theater building, organisations for
drama reform, ' ; little theater " movements,
and all pertinent subjects.
Significant books on dramaturgy are
reviewe
d.
Single copies, seventy-five cents.
Yearly Subscription, three dollars.
I'rinteil by PABTAIDGE & Cooper, Ltd.. Fleet Street. London, B.C., ami published by the Proprietors,
I ii i vtw Krkewoma.n, Ltd., at Oakley llou-c. l;loomsbnry Street. London W.C.